Viana Maria Carmen, Kazdin Alan E, Harris Meredith G, Stein Dan J, Vigo Daniel V, Hwang Irving, Manoukian Sophie M, Sampson Nancy A, Alonso Jordi, Andrade Laura Helena, Borges Guilherme, Bunting Brendan, Caldas-de-Almeida José Miguel, de Girolamo Giovanni, de Jonge Peter, Gureje Oye, Haro Josep Maria, Karam Elie G, Kovess-Masfety Viviane, Moskalewicz Jacek, Navarro-Mateu Fernando, Nishi Daisuke, Piazza Marina, Posada-Villa José, Scott Kate M, Vladescu Cristian, Wojtyniak Bogdan, Zarkov Zahari, Kessler Ronald C, Kessler Timothy
Department of Social Medicine, Postgraduate Program in Public Health, Federal University of Espírito Santo, Av. Marechal Campos, 1468, Vitória, ES, CEP 29.043-900, Brazil.
Department of Psychology, Yale University, 2 Hillhouse Avenue, 208205, New Haven, CT, 06520, USA.
Int J Ment Health Syst. 2025 Feb 9;19(1):6. doi: 10.1186/s13033-024-00658-2.
High unmet need for treatment of mental disorders exists throughout the world. An understanding of barriers to treatment is needed to develop effective programs to address this problem.
Data on barriers were obtained from face-to-face interviews in 22 community surveys across 19 countries (n = 102,812 respondents aged ≥ 18 years, 57.7% female, median age [interquartile range]: 43 [31-57] years; 68.5% weighted average response rate) in the World Mental Health (WMH) surveys. We focus on the n = 5,136 respondents with 12-month DSM-IV anxiety, mood, or substance use disorders with perceived need for treatment. The n = 2,444 such respondents who did not receive treatment were asked about barriers to receiving treatment, whereas the n = 926 respondents who received treatment with a delay were asked about barriers leading to delays. Consistent with previous research, we distinguished five broad classes of barriers: low perceived disorder severity, two types of barriers in the domain of predisposing factors (beliefs/attitudes about treatment ineffectiveness and stigma) and two types in the domain of enabling factors (financial and nonfinancial). Baseline predictors of receiving treatment found in a prior report (i.e., comparing the n = 2,692 respondents who received treatment with the n = 2,444 who did not) were examined as predictors of barriers, while barriers were examined as mediators of associations between these predictors and treatment.
Most respondents reported multiple barriers. Barriers among respondents who did not receive treatment included low perceived severity (52.9%), perceived treatment ineffectiveness (44.8%), nonfinancial (40.2%) and financial (32.9%) barriers in the domain of enabling factors, and stigma (20.6%). Barriers causing delays in treatment had a similar rank-order but were reported by higher proportions of respondents (X = 3.8-199.8, p = 0.050- < 0.001). Barriers were predicted by low education, disorder type, age, employment status, and financial obstacles. Predictors varied as a function of barrier type.
A wide range of barriers to treatment exist among people with mental disorders even after a need for treatment is acknowledged. Most such individuals have multiple barriers. These results have important implications for the design of programs to decrease unmet need for treatment of mental disorders.
世界各地对精神障碍治疗的未满足需求很高。需要了解治疗障碍,以制定有效的计划来解决这一问题。
在世界心理健康(WMH)调查中,通过对19个国家的22项社区调查进行面对面访谈获取有关障碍的数据(n = 102812名年龄≥18岁的受访者,57.7%为女性,年龄中位数[四分位间距]:43[31 - 57]岁;加权平均回应率为68.5%)。我们关注n = 5136名有12个月DSM-IV焦虑、情绪或物质使用障碍且认为需要治疗 的受访者。n = 2444名未接受治疗的此类受访者被问及接受治疗的障碍,而n = 926名延迟接受治疗的受访者被问及导致延迟的障碍。与先前研究一致,我们区分了五大类障碍:低感知障碍严重程度、易患因素领域的两类障碍(对治疗无效性的信念/态度和污名)以及促成因素领域的两类障碍(经济和非经济)。将先前报告中发现的接受治疗的基线预测因素(即比较接受治疗的n = 2692名受访者与未接受治疗的n = 2444名受访者)作为障碍的预测因素进行检验,同时将障碍作为这些预测因素与治疗之间关联的中介进行检验。
大多数受访者报告了多种障碍。未接受治疗的受访者中的障碍包括低感知严重程度(52.9%)、感知治疗无效性(44.8%)、促成因素领域的非经济(40.2%)和经济(32.9%)障碍以及污名(20.6%)。导致治疗延迟的障碍有类似的排序,但报告的受访者比例更高(X = 3.8 - 199.8,p = 0.050 - <0.001)。障碍由低教育程度、障碍类型、年龄、就业状况和经济障碍预测。预测因素因障碍类型而异。
即使在承认需要治疗之后,精神障碍患者中仍存在广泛的治疗障碍。大多数此类个体有多种障碍。这些结果对减少精神障碍治疗未满足需求的计划设计具有重要意义。