The healthy human infant gut microbiome undergoes stereotypical changes in taxonomic composition between birth and maturation to an adult-like stable state. During this time, extensive communication between microbiota and the host immune system contributes to health status later in life. Although there are many reported associations between microbiota compositional alterations and disease in adults, less is known about how microbiome development is altered in pediatric diseases. One pediatric disease linked to altered gut microbiota composition is cystic fibrosis (CF), a multi-organ genetic disease involving impaired chloride secretion across epithelia and heightened inflammation both in the gut and at other body sites. Here, we use shotgun metagenomics to profile the strain-level composition and developmental dynamics of the infant fecal microbiota from several CF and non-CF longitudinal cohorts spanning from birth to greater than 36 months of life. We identify a set of keystone species that define microbiota development in early life in non-CF infants but are missing or decreased in relative abundance in infants with CF, resulting in a delayed pattern of microbiota maturation, persistent entrenchment in a transitional developmental phase, and subsequent failure to attain an adult-like stable microbiota. Delayed maturation is strongly associated with cumulative antibiotic treatments, and we also detect the increased relative abundance of oral-derived bacteria and higher levels of fungi in infants with CF, features that are associated with decreased gut bacterial density. These findings suggest the potential for future directed therapies targeted at overcoming developmental delays in microbiota maturation for infants with CF.IMPORTANCEThe human gastrointestinal tract harbors a diversity of microbes that colonize upon birth and collectively contribute to host health throughout life. Infants with the disease cystic fibrosis (CF) harbor altered gut microbiota compared to non-CF counterparts, with lower levels of beneficial bacteria. How this altered population is established in infants with CF and how it develops over the first years of life is not well understood. By leveraging multiple large non-CF infant fecal metagenomic data sets and samples from a CF cohort collected prior to highly effective modulator therapy, we define microbiome maturation in infants up to 3 years of age. Our findings identify conserved age-diagnostic species in the non-CF infant microbiome that are diminished in abundance in CF counterparts that instead exhibit an enrichment of oral-derived bacteria and fungi associated with antibiotic exposure. Together, our study builds toward microbiota-targeted therapy to restore healthy microbiota dynamics in infants with CF.