Jiwani Safia S, Rana Saqib, Hazel Elizabeth A, Maïga Abdoulaye, Wilson Emily B, Amouzou Agbessi
J Glob Health. 2025 Feb 14;15:04048. doi: 10.7189/jogh.15.04048.
Substantial gaps exist between pregnant women's contact with health facilities and the quality of care they receive (effective coverage) in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs). An effective coverage cascade is a useful analytical approach to uncover gaps due to poor facility service readiness and quality of care. We estimated readiness-adjusted antenatal care (ANC) coverage and built an effective coverage cascade in countries with available data.
We used data from latest household and health facility surveys in eight countries accounting for 28 925 women and 8621 facilities. Service readiness was assessed based on the availability of core items needed to provide quality ANC. We linked the household surveys with health facility data by subnational region and facility type to estimate readiness-adjusted ANC coverage for at least one, four, and eight or more ANC contacts and ANC content. We built a four-step ANC effective coverage cascade and calculated loss of coverage in terms of ANC readiness coverage gaps and missed opportunities.
The majority of women sought ANC services in lower-level facilities, except in Bangladesh, Nepal and Senegal. While at least one antenatal care contact (ANC1+) service coverage was high, ranging from 89.2% (95% confidence interval (CI) = 87.2-90.9) in Haiti to 98.1% (95% CI = 97.5-98.6) in Malawi, readiness-adjusted ANC1+ coverage was lower, ranging from 64% (95% CI = 62.4-65.5) in Haiti to 76.2% (95% CI = 75.1-77.2) in Nepal. We obtained readiness gaps as high as 33.7 percentage points in Malawi and missed opportunities of 21 percentage points in Tanzania. Poor diagnostic capacity and insufficient trained human resources drove the low ANC facility readiness. We found large inequalities in readiness-adjusted ANC1+ by socioeconomic status favouring wealthier and urban resident women.
The effective coverage cascade for ANC services helped uncover large readiness gaps, missed opportunities, and socioeconomic inequalities. Improvements in facilities' diagnostic capacity and availability of trained human resources will enhance their ability to provide high quality health services and ensure health gains.
在低收入和中等收入国家(LMICs),孕妇与卫生设施的接触情况和她们所接受的护理质量(有效覆盖率)之间存在巨大差距。有效的覆盖率级联是一种有用的分析方法,可用于揭示由于设施服务准备不足和护理质量差而导致的差距。我们在有可用数据的国家中估计了调整准备情况后的产前护理(ANC)覆盖率,并构建了有效的覆盖率级联。
我们使用了来自八个国家最新的家庭和卫生设施调查数据,涉及28925名妇女和8621个设施。根据提供高质量ANC所需核心项目的可用性来评估服务准备情况。我们按次国家级区域和设施类型将家庭调查与卫生设施数据相联系,以估计至少进行一次、四次以及八次或更多次ANC接触和ANC内容的调整准备情况后的ANC覆盖率。我们构建了一个四步的ANC有效覆盖率级联,并根据ANC准备情况覆盖率差距和错失机会计算覆盖率损失。
除了孟加拉国、尼泊尔和塞内加尔外,大多数妇女在较低级别的设施中寻求ANC服务。虽然至少进行一次产前护理接触(ANC1 +)服务覆盖率很高,从海地的89.2%(95%置信区间(CI)= 87.2 - 90.9)到马拉维的98.1%(95% CI = 97.5 - 98.6),但调整准备情况后的ANC1 +覆盖率较低,从海地的64%(95% CI = 62.4 - 65.5)到尼泊尔的76.2%(95% CI = 75.1 - 77.2)。我们在马拉维获得了高达33.7个百分点的准备情况差距,在坦桑尼亚有21个百分点的错失机会。诊断能力差和训练有素的人力资源不足导致了ANC设施准备情况不佳。我们发现,按社会经济地位调整准备情况后的ANC1 +存在很大不平等,富裕和城市居民妇女占优势。
ANC服务的有效覆盖率级联有助于揭示巨大的准备情况差距、错失机会和社会经济不平等。提高设施的诊断能力和训练有素的人力资源的可用性将增强其提供高质量卫生服务的能力,并确保健康收益。