Sharma Saraswati, Mahotra Anita, Thapa Tulsi Ram, Thapa Pushpa, Bhandary Shital, Bhushal Suraj, Paudel Sudarshan
Health Office Gulmi, Health Directorate, Ministry of Health, Gulmi District, Lumbini Province, Nepal.
Faculty of Medicine, Public Health and Nursing (FKKMK), Universitas Gadjah Mada (UGM), Yogyakarta, Indonesia.
BMC Public Health. 2025 Feb 25;25(1):771. doi: 10.1186/s12889-025-21972-5.
Acknowledging the unique health needs of school children, the Government of Nepal launched the "One School One Nurse" initiative, which was first implemented by the Provincial Government of Bagmati Province in 2018/2019. The program aims to improve health outcomes among school children by deploying a certified nurse in community schools who provides preventive healthcare, health education and first-aid services. Though the program is being scaled up over provinces, it is in its initial stage of development and there are scarce published literature available about the program. This limited availability of comprehensive resources evaluating the program's usage and supportive and hindering factors demands further investigation on it. Thus, this study assessed the utilization of school nurse services among secondary students and identified the factors associated with service utilization quantitatively. Also, the study explored the underlying factors influencing school nurse service utilization qualitatively. Finally, the study did the triangulation to cross-validate the findings from both quantitative and qualitative studies.
A concurrent triangulation mixed-method study was conducted in six public schools randomly selected from each of six local levels of Lalitpur district implementing the ''One school one nurse'' program. Quantitative data were collected from 280 students in grades 9-12 using a self-administered questionnaire. Qualitative data were gathered through in-depth interviews with ten students and key informant interviews with six school staff including school nurses and teachers. Data collection was done from November 2022 to January 2023. Quantitative data were analyzed using weighted multivariable logistic regression to determine predictors of school nurse service utilization. For the qualitative component, a deductive approach based on the socioecological framework was employed to explore factors influencing service utilization.
The school nurse service utilization rate among secondary students was 28.69% in Lalitpur. The odds of utilizing the service were two times higher among students below 16 years (AOR: 2.08, 95% CI: 1.07-4.02) compared to older students. Additionally, those motivated by teachers, school nurses and parents had four times higher odds of utilization of the service (AOR: 4.16, 95% CI: 1.26-13.64) compared to those without such external encouragement. Conversely, students having learning difficulties had about 68% lower odds of utilizing the school nurse service (AOR: 0.316, CI:0.134-0.744) compared to the student without such difficulties. Triangulation of findings from both studies revealed factors like age, sex, External motivation, student awareness about services and learning difficulty influenced service utilization. Moreover, frequent turnover of school nurses, their absence in school during their training sessions or external programs and insufficient coordination between provincial, local, and school authorities significantly hindered students' access to services. Ethical approval for the study was obtained by the Institutional Review Committee of Patan Academy of Health Sciences (Ref: PHP2209301678).
Around one third of secondary students utilized the school nurse services in past one year in Lalitpur district. Enhancing awareness and motivation among students, with a particular focus on older students, male students, and those with learning difficulties, could help increase service utilization rates. Additionally, implementing better staffing strategies and strengthening coordination among stakeholders would enhance program effectiveness, ultimately leading to improved service access. Further research is recommended to examine factors that positively or negatively impact the program at a broader level, incorporating insights from divisional and local level authorities.
尼泊尔政府认识到在校儿童独特的健康需求,发起了“一校一护士”倡议,该倡议于2018/2019年由加德满都省省级政府首次实施。该计划旨在通过在社区学校部署一名注册护士来改善在校儿童的健康状况,该护士提供预防性医疗保健、健康教育和急救服务。尽管该计划正在各省推广,但仍处于发展初期,关于该计划的已发表文献很少。评估该计划使用情况以及支持和阻碍因素的综合资源有限,需要对此进行进一步调查。因此,本研究定量评估了中学生对学校护士服务的利用情况,并确定了与服务利用相关的因素。此外,该研究定性探讨了影响学校护士服务利用的潜在因素。最后,该研究进行了三角验证,以交叉验证定量和定性研究的结果。
在拉利特布尔区六个地方一级各随机选择的六所公立学校中进行了一项同时三角验证的混合方法研究,这些学校正在实施“一校一护士”计划。使用自填式问卷从280名9至12年级的学生中收集定量数据。通过对十名学生的深入访谈和对包括学校护士和教师在内的六名学校工作人员的关键信息访谈收集定性数据。数据收集于2022年11月至2023年1月进行。使用加权多变量逻辑回归分析定量数据,以确定学校护士服务利用的预测因素。对于定性部分,采用基于社会生态框架的演绎方法来探索影响服务利用的因素。
在拉利特布尔,中学生对学校护士服务的利用率为28.69%。与年龄较大的学生相比,16岁以下的学生使用该服务的几率高出两倍(调整后的比值比:2.08,95%置信区间:1.07 - 4.02)。此外,受到教师、学校护士和家长激励的学生使用该服务的几率比没有这种外部鼓励的学生高出四倍(调整后的比值比:4.16,95%置信区间:1.26 - 13.64)。相反,与没有学习困难的学生相比,有学习困难的学生使用学校护士服务的几率低约68%(调整后的比值比:0.316,置信区间:0.134 - 0.744)。两项研究结果的三角验证表明,年龄、性别、外部动机、学生对服务的认知和学习困难等因素影响服务利用。此外,学校护士频繁更换、在培训课程或外部项目期间不在学校以及省级、地方和学校当局之间协调不足,严重阻碍了学生获得服务。该研究获得了帕坦健康科学学院机构审查委员会的伦理批准(参考号:PHP2209301678)。
在拉利特布尔区,约三分之一的中学生在过去一年中使用了学校护士服务。提高学生的意识和积极性,特别是关注年龄较大的学生、男学生和有学习困难的学生,有助于提高服务利用率。此外,实施更好的人员配备策略并加强利益相关者之间的协调将提高项目效果,最终改善服务获取情况。建议进一步研究,从分区和地方当局的见解出发,在更广泛层面上审视对该项目产生积极或消极影响的因素。