Wiedermann Christian J, Plagg Barbara, Rina Patrick, Piccoliori Giuliano, Engl Adolf
Institute of General Practice and Public Health, College of Health Professions-Claudiana, 39100 Bolzano, Italy.
Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2025 Feb 6;22(2):230. doi: 10.3390/ijerph22020230.
Vaccine hesitancy presents a significant challenge to public health, particularly in culturally diverse regions, such as South Tyrol, Italy. This article examines the interplay between political influences, conspiracy theories, and vaccine hesitancy in South Tyrol, an autonomous province characterised by its linguistic diversity and historical scepticism toward central authority. This study aimed to identify the important drivers of vaccine hesitancy and propose targeted strategies to enhance vaccine acceptance. Peer-reviewed and grey literature was examined to explore the sociocultural factors, political dynamics, and conspiracy narratives influencing vaccine hesitancy in South Tyrol. The analysis incorporated publicly available materials, including propaganda from anti-vaccine organisations, and regional public health data to contextualise the findings. Vaccine hesitancy in South Tyrol was influenced by historical tensions with the central government, cultural alignment with Austrian healthcare practices, and politically motivated opposition to vaccination. Conspiracy theories disseminated by local organisations and political entities exploit concerns regarding governmental overreach and personal autonomy. These dynamics are compounded by the selective misrepresentation of scientific discourse, which further polarises public opinion. Addressing vaccine hesitancy in South Tyrol requires culturally sensitive communication, community engagement through trusted local figures, transparency in health policies, and the proactive monitoring of misinformation. These strategies can mitigate mistrust and promote vaccine acceptance in regions with similar sociopolitical complexities.
疫苗犹豫对公共卫生构成了重大挑战,尤其是在文化多元的地区,如意大利的南蒂罗尔。本文探讨了南蒂罗尔(一个以语言多样性和对中央权威的历史怀疑态度为特征的自治省)政治影响、阴谋论与疫苗犹豫之间的相互作用。本研究旨在确定疫苗犹豫的重要驱动因素,并提出有针对性的策略以提高疫苗接种率。通过审查同行评审文献和灰色文献,探讨影响南蒂罗尔疫苗犹豫的社会文化因素、政治动态和阴谋论叙事。分析纳入了公开可用的材料,包括反疫苗组织的宣传资料以及地区公共卫生数据,以便将研究结果置于具体情境中。南蒂罗尔的疫苗犹豫受到与中央政府的历史紧张关系、与奥地利医疗实践的文化契合度以及出于政治动机对疫苗接种的反对等因素的影响。当地组织和政治实体传播的阴谋论利用了人们对政府权力扩张和个人自主权的担忧。科学话语的选择性歪曲加剧了这些动态,进一步使公众舆论两极分化。解决南蒂罗尔的疫苗犹豫问题需要具有文化敏感性的沟通、通过受信任的当地人物进行社区参与、卫生政策的透明度以及对错误信息的积极监测。这些策略可以减少不信任,并在具有类似社会政治复杂性的地区促进疫苗接种。