Liu Fanghua, Yang Yanchao, Wang Feng Robin, Li Wangze
School of Graduates, Changchun Normal University, Changchun, Jilin Province, People's Republic of China.
Institute of International Language Services Studies, Macau Millennium College, Macau SAR, People's Republic of China.
PLoS One. 2025 Feb 26;20(2):e0314879. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0314879. eCollection 2025.
The importance of English debate in fostering critical thinking and the role of self-efficacy in enhancing confidence and performance in this domain are widely acknowledged. However, a significant gap exists in the literature regarding the measurement of self-efficacy specifically within English debate. This research seeks to fill this gap by developing and validating an English Debate Self-Efficacy Scale (EDSS). Using a sample of 1,259 participants from an independent college in Hebei Province, China, the study divided participants into two groups: 613 for exploratory factor analysis (EFA) and 646 for confirmatory factor analysis (CFA), with convenience sampling as the chosen methodology. EFA revealed three core dimensions of debate-related self-efficacy: Language proficiency (Cronbach's Alpha = .894), Debating skills (Cronbach's Alpha = .861), and Team collaboration (Cronbach's Alpha = .831). Subsequent CFA validation with an independent sample confirmed the scale's structure, demonstrating strong structural, convergent, and discriminant validity. Additionally, significant correlations between the English Debate Self-Efficacy Scale and the English Proficiency Self-Efficacy Scale supported the scale's criterion validity. These findings underscore the scale's potential as a reliable tool for assessing self-efficacy in English debate contexts, offering valuable insights for research, teaching, and training in educational settings. Limitations related to sample representativeness and research design were also discussed, providing a foundation for future studies to expand upon. In conclusion, the English Debate Self-Efficacy Scale (EDSS) is a reliable and valid instrument for measuring self-efficacy in the context of English debate.
英语辩论在培养批判性思维方面的重要性以及自我效能感在增强该领域自信心和表现方面的作用已得到广泛认可。然而,关于在英语辩论中具体测量自我效能感的文献存在显著空白。本研究旨在通过开发和验证英语辩论自我效能量表(EDSS)来填补这一空白。该研究以中国河北省一所独立学院的1259名参与者为样本,将参与者分为两组:613名用于探索性因素分析(EFA),646名用于验证性因素分析(CFA),采用便利抽样作为选定的方法。探索性因素分析揭示了与辩论相关的自我效能感的三个核心维度:语言能力(克朗巴哈系数α =.894)、辩论技巧(克朗巴哈系数α =.861)和团队协作(克朗巴哈系数α =.831)。随后用独立样本进行的验证性因素分析证实了该量表的结构,显示出很强的结构效度、收敛效度和区分效度。此外,英语辩论自我效能量表与英语能力自我效能量表之间的显著相关性支持了该量表的效标效度。这些发现强调了该量表作为评估英语辩论中自我效能感的可靠工具的潜力,为教育环境中的研究、教学和培训提供了有价值的见解。还讨论了与样本代表性和研究设计相关的局限性,为未来研究的拓展奠定了基础。总之,英语辩论自我效能量表(EDSS)是测量英语辩论中自我效能感的可靠且有效的工具。