Wah Jack Ng Kok
Multimedia University, Cyberjaya, Malaysia.
Front Public Health. 2025 Feb 13;13:1530799. doi: 10.3389/fpubh.2025.1530799. eCollection 2025.
INTRODUCTION: The integration of Artificial Intelligence (AI) in healthcare, particularly through hybrid chatbots, is reshaping the industry by enhancing service delivery, patient engagement, and clinical outcomes. These chatbots combine AI with human input to provide intelligent, personalized interactions in areas like diagnostics, chronic disease management, and mental health support. However, gaps remain in trust, data security, system integration, and user experience, which hinder widespread adoption. Key challenges include the hesitancy of patients to trust AI due to concerns over data privacy and the accuracy of medical advice, as well as difficulties in integrating chatbots into existing healthcare infrastructures. The review aims to assess the effectiveness of hybrid AI chatbots in improving healthcare outcomes, reducing costs, and enhancing patient engagement, while identifying barriers to adoption such as cultural adaptability and trust issues. The novelty of the review lies in its comprehensive exploration of both technological advancements and the socio-emotional factors influencing chatbot acceptance. METHODS: The review follows a systematic methodology with four core components: eligibility criteria, review selection, data extraction, and data synthesis. Studies focused on AI applications and hybrid chatbots in healthcare, particularly in chronic disease management and mental health support, were included. Publications from 2022 to 2025 were prioritized, and peer-reviewed sources in English were considered. After screening 116 studies, 29 met the criteria for inclusion. Data was extracted using a structured template, capturing study objectives, methodologies, findings, and challenges. Thematic analysis was applied to identify four themes: AI applications, technical advancements, user adoption, and challenges/ethical concerns. Statistical and content analysis methods were employed to synthesize the data comprehensively, ensuring robustness in the findings. RESULTS: Hybrid chatbots in healthcare have shown significant benefits, such as reducing hospital readmissions by up to 25%, improving patient engagement by 30%, and cutting consultation wait times by 15%. They are widely used for chronic disease management, mental health support, and patient education, demonstrating their efficiency in both developed and developing countries. DISCUSSION: The review concludes that overcoming these barriers through infrastructure investment, training, and enhanced transparency is crucial for maximizing the potential of AI in healthcare. Future researchers should focus on long-term outcomes, addressing ethical considerations, and expanding cross-cultural adaptability. Limitations of the review include the narrow scope of some case studies and the absence of long-term data on AI's efficacy in diverse healthcare contexts. Further studies are needed to explore these challenges and the long-term impact of AI-driven healthcare solutions.
引言:人工智能(AI)在医疗保健领域的整合,特别是通过混合聊天机器人,正在通过改善服务提供、患者参与度和临床结果来重塑该行业。这些聊天机器人将人工智能与人工输入相结合,在诊断、慢性病管理和心理健康支持等领域提供智能、个性化的互动。然而,在信任、数据安全、系统集成和用户体验方面仍然存在差距,这阻碍了其广泛应用。关键挑战包括患者由于对数据隐私和医疗建议准确性的担忧而对信任人工智能犹豫不决,以及将聊天机器人集成到现有医疗保健基础设施中的困难。本综述旨在评估混合人工智能聊天机器人在改善医疗保健结果、降低成本和提高患者参与度方面的有效性,同时确定诸如文化适应性和信任问题等采用障碍。该综述的新颖之处在于其对技术进步和影响聊天机器人接受度的社会情感因素进行了全面探索。 方法:本综述采用一种系统的方法,包括四个核心部分:纳入标准、文献筛选、数据提取和数据综合。纳入了关注人工智能在医疗保健领域的应用以及混合聊天机器人,特别是在慢性病管理和心理健康支持方面的研究。优先考虑2022年至2025年的出版物,并考虑英文同行评审来源。在筛选了116项研究后,29项符合纳入标准。使用结构化模板提取数据,涵盖研究目标、方法、结果和挑战。应用主题分析来确定四个主题:人工智能应用、技术进步、用户采用以及挑战/伦理问题。采用统计和内容分析方法对数据进行全面综合,确保研究结果的稳健性。 结果:医疗保健领域的混合聊天机器人已显示出显著益处,例如将医院再入院率降低多达25%,将患者参与度提高30%,并将咨询等待时间缩短15%。它们广泛用于慢性病管理、心理健康支持和患者教育,在发达国家和发展中国家都证明了其效率。 讨论:该综述得出结论,通过基础设施投资、培训和提高透明度来克服这些障碍对于最大限度发挥人工智能在医疗保健领域的潜力至关重要。未来的研究人员应关注长期结果,解决伦理问题,并扩大跨文化适应性。该综述的局限性包括一些案例研究的范围较窄,以及缺乏关于人工智能在不同医疗保健环境中疗效的长期数据。需要进一步的研究来探索这些挑战以及人工智能驱动的医疗保健解决方案的长期影响。
Front Public Health. 2025-2-13
J Robot Surg. 2025-1-7
Health Soc Care Deliv Res. 2025-5-21
J Med Internet Res. 2025-4-4
Health Technol Assess. 2001
J Health Organ Manag. 2025-6-30
Front Digit Health. 2025-8-18
J Multidiscip Healthc. 2024-11-9
Front Digit Health. 2024-3-8
J Med Internet Res. 2023-2-24