Schwebel Frank J, Wilson Adam D, Pearson Matthew R, McCool Matison W, Witkiewitz Katie
University of New Mexico, USA.
University of New Mexico, USA.
Addict Behav. 2025 Jun;165:108273. doi: 10.1016/j.addbeh.2025.108273. Epub 2025 Feb 25.
Recent investigations of recovery from alcohol use disorder (AUD) have distinguished subgroups of high and low functioning recovery in data from randomized controlled trials of behavioral treatments for AUD. Analyses considered various indicators of alcohol use, life satisfaction, and psychosocial functioning, and identified four recovery profiles from AUD three years following treatment.
The present study integrates these profiles into a two-part machine learning framework, using recursive partitioning and random forests to distinguish a) clinical cut-points across 28 end-of-treatment biopsychosocial measurements that are predictive of high or low functioning recovery three years after treatment; and b) a rank-ordered list of the most salient variables for predicting individual membership in the high-functioning recovery sub-groups.
This secondary data analysis includes individuals (n = 809; 29.7% female) in the outpatient arm of Project MATCH who completed the end-of-treatment assessment and three-year follow-up batteries.
Recursive partitioning found individuals with low depressive symptoms and less than 25% drinking days were more likely to be in a high functioning recovery profile (68%), whereas those with at least mild depressive symptoms and low purpose in life were more likely to be in a low functioning recovery profile (70%). Random forests identified purpose in life, social functioning, and depressive symptoms as the best predictors of recovery profiles.
Recovery profiles are best predicted by variables often considered of secondary interest. We demonstrate the utility of two machine learning approaches, highlighting how random forests can overcome recursive partitioning limitations.
近期对酒精使用障碍(AUD)康复情况的调查在AUD行为治疗随机对照试验的数据中区分出了高功能和低功能康复亚组。分析考虑了酒精使用、生活满意度和心理社会功能的各种指标,并确定了治疗三年后AUD的四种康复概况。
本研究将这些概况整合到一个两部分的机器学习框架中,使用递归划分和随机森林来区分:a)28项治疗结束时生物心理社会测量指标的临床切点,这些指标可预测治疗三年后高功能或低功能康复情况;b)预测高功能康复亚组个体成员身份的最显著变量的排序列表。
这项二次数据分析包括来自MATCH项目门诊组的个体(n = 809;29.7%为女性),他们完成了治疗结束评估和三年随访。
递归划分发现,抑郁症状较轻且饮酒天数少于25%的个体更有可能处于高功能康复概况(68%),而至少有轻度抑郁症状且生活目标较低的个体更有可能处于低功能康复概况(70%)。随机森林确定生活目标、社会功能和抑郁症状是康复概况的最佳预测指标。
康复概况最好由通常被视为次要关注点的变量来预测。我们展示了两种机器学习方法的效用,强调了随机森林如何能够克服递归划分的局限性。