Simons Kyra, Mendrek Adrianna, Piché Jasmine, Bernier Megan, Léger-Goodes Terra, Malboeuf-Hurtubise Catherine
Bishop's University (Psychology), Sherbrooke, QC, Canada.
University of Quebec at Montreal (Psychology), Montreal, QC, Canada.
BMC Psychol. 2025 Mar 3;13(1):182. doi: 10.1186/s40359-025-02476-8.
Children in rural communities are of the most vulnerable populations in Canada. Living in a rural community has mental health and well-being implications for these children, particularly regarding their access to mental health services. By comparison to talk therapies, which are often costly, art-based interventions are accessible financially, geographically (i.e., offered in academic settings), and across abilities. Qualitative research of art-based approaches with vulnerable children is limited. Despite this, art-based interventions have allowed children to express their feelings through art, which in turn helped them identify and verbalize thoughts and feelings; something that youth tend to struggle with in traditional psychotherapy. As such, considering the vulnerable context of the students in the present research, a community-based approach was deemed beneficial-and thus adopted-in the current project as we created art with underprivileged children in a rural community with a specific focus on promoting positive mental health.
The purpose of this project was to examine the experiences and preliminary impact of an art-based intervention with students in rural communities.
27 youth from Quebec, Canada, aged 10-12 took part in a weekly art-based intervention for 7 weeks that was designed to cater to their unique needs. The intervention design and specific art activities were chosen according to the community partners' description of the students' needs and previous work led by the research team which aimed to improve elementary school children's mental health. An ethnographic approach was used to examine the implications this intervention had on students, particularly their mental health and well-being. Thematic analysis was used to examine the data.
The majority of students reported enjoying the intervention, many stating it had a positive impact on their lives. For example, various students reported that the intervention made them feel more comfortable amongst their peers and program staff. Students also reported feeling positively during art-making and expressed interest in taking part in follow-up research.
Overall, positive experiences with the present intervention support existing literature regarding the effectiveness of art-based methods for youth populations. Future research should further investigate the importance of the therapeutic alliance in youth community- and art-based research, particularly how the age of the facilitator can enhance rapport. Additionally, further research is needed to understand how art-based interventions, although sometimes unenjoyable, can have positive implications through pushing personal limits.
加拿大农村社区的儿童是最脆弱的群体之一。生活在农村社区对这些儿童的心理健康和幸福感有影响,特别是在获得心理健康服务方面。与通常成本高昂的谈话疗法相比,基于艺术的干预在经济上、地理上(即在学术环境中提供)以及针对不同能力的人群方面都更容易获得。针对弱势儿童的基于艺术方法的定性研究有限。尽管如此,基于艺术的干预让儿童通过艺术表达自己的感受,这反过来又帮助他们识别并说出想法和感受;而这正是青少年在传统心理治疗中往往难以做到的。因此,考虑到本研究中学生的弱势背景,在当前项目中采用基于社区的方法被认为是有益的——我们与农村社区的贫困儿童一起创作艺术作品,特别注重促进积极的心理健康。
本项目的目的是研究基于艺术的干预对农村社区学生的体验和初步影响。
来自加拿大魁北克的27名10至12岁的青少年参加了为期7周的每周一次的基于艺术的干预,该干预旨在满足他们的独特需求。干预设计和具体的艺术活动是根据社区合作伙伴对学生需求的描述以及研究团队之前旨在改善小学生心理健康的工作来选择的。采用人种志方法来研究这种干预对学生的影响,特别是对他们心理健康和幸福感的影响。使用主题分析法来分析数据。
大多数学生表示喜欢这种干预,许多人表示它对他们的生活有积极影响。例如,不同的学生报告说,这种干预让他们在同龄人及项目工作人员中感觉更自在。学生们还报告说在创作艺术作品时感觉良好,并表示有兴趣参与后续研究。
总体而言,本次干预的积极体验支持了现有关于基于艺术的方法对青少年群体有效性的文献。未来的研究应进一步调查治疗联盟在青少年社区和基于艺术研究中的重要性,特别是促进者的年龄如何能增强融洽关系。此外,还需要进一步研究以了解基于艺术的干预尽管有时不那么令人愉快,但如何通过挑战个人极限产生积极影响。