Rahimi Samira Abbasgholizadeh, Baradaran Ashkan, Khameneifar Farbod, Gore Genevieve, Issa Amalia M
IEEE J Biomed Health Inform. 2024 Dec 24;PP. doi: 10.1109/JBHI.2024.3521717.
AI-enabled digital twins (DTs) are advanced virtual models of a complex real-world system, augmented with predictive AI capabilities, which have a potential for transforming healthcare and clincial decision making. Despite the growing interest and need in such DTs, the literature lacks a unified framework for its development and implementation.
This study aims to map the existing knowledge on AI-enabled DTs for clinical decision-making, and develop a comprehensive framework for its development and implementation.
Informed by the scoping review frameworks established by Arksey and O'Malley, and the Joanna Briggs Institute, we performed a scoping review of studies reporting on the development and implementation of AI-enabled DTs for clinical decision-making in any healthcare setting. The search strategy was developed by a professional academic librarian for three databases, i.e., PubMed, Embase (Ovid), and IEEE Xplore, from the date of inception until August 2023. We also conducted a grey literature search on Google Scholar. Moreover, we scanned the references of all included studies to identify additional potentially relevant studies for inclusion. A reviewer screened titles and abstracts, full-text articles, and charted data, and the second reviewer verified them. Data were summarised descriptively using content analysis. Key steps in DTs development were identified and combined to create the DECIDE-Twin framework.
Out of 421 records, 11 were included: seven reviews and four empirical studies, all published from 2020 onward. The reviews contained either a framework or information that was used to construct our newly developed framework. The empirical studies reported the development of DTs, and one reported a common infrastructure for a wide range of applications for DTs.
We developed the DECIDE-Twin framework that could serve as a guide for researchers and practitioners for the development and implementation of AI-enabled DTs in clinical decision making. Further research is needed to validate and implement this framework across various use cases.
人工智能驱动的数字孪生(DTs)是复杂现实世界系统的先进虚拟模型,具备预测性人工智能能力,具有变革医疗保健和临床决策的潜力。尽管人们对此类数字孪生的兴趣和需求日益增长,但文献中缺乏其开发和实施的统一框架。
本研究旨在梳理关于用于临床决策的人工智能驱动数字孪生的现有知识,并为其开发和实施制定一个全面的框架。
依据阿克西和奥马利以及乔安娜·布里格斯研究所建立的范围综述框架,我们对在任何医疗环境中报告用于临床决策的人工智能驱动数字孪生的开发和实施的研究进行了范围综述。搜索策略由专业学术图书馆员针对三个数据库制定,即PubMed、Embase(Ovid)和IEEE Xplore,从起始日期至2023年8月。我们还在谷歌学术上进行了灰色文献搜索。此外,我们浏览了所有纳入研究的参考文献,以识别其他可能相关的纳入研究。一名评审员筛选标题和摘要、全文文章并绘制数据,第二名评审员进行核实。使用内容分析对数据进行描述性总结。确定并合并数字孪生开发中的关键步骤,以创建DECIDE - Twin框架。
在421条记录中,纳入了11条:7篇综述和4篇实证研究报告,均发表于2020年以后。这些综述包含一个框架或用于构建我们新开发框架的信息。实证研究报告了数字孪生的开发情况,其中一篇报告了数字孪生广泛应用的通用基础设施。
我们开发了DECIDE - Twin框架,可为研究人员和从业者在临床决策中开发和实施人工智能驱动的数字孪生提供指导。需要进一步研究以在各种用例中验证和实施该框架。