Dupuis Roxanne, Musicus Aviva A, Edghill Brittany, Keteku Emma, Bragg Marie A
Department of Population Health, NYU Grossman School of Medicine, New York, NY, United States.
NYU Food Environment and Policy Research Coalition, New York, NY, United States.
J Med Internet Res. 2025 Feb 28;27:e60891. doi: 10.2196/60891.
Food and beverage marketing is an important influence on the health and diets of adolescents. Food and beverage companies spend billions of dollars annually on advertisements to promote their products and are increasingly focusing on social media influencers. Influencer product endorsements blur the line between entertainment and marketing.
This study aimed to quantify how often TikTok influencers promote products from food and beverage brands and document the range of ways they disclose brand relationships in their content.
We collected up to 100 videos posted on or before July 1, 2022, from each of the top 100 influencers on TikTok in the United States and recorded information about the influencer (eg, number of followers) and video (eg, number of views and likes). For each video that contained food or beverage products, we identified the main product featured. A team of research assistants then coded each video for how the product was featured (ie, in the video, audio, or caption) and, for branded products, whether the video was accompanied by any disclosures of brand relationships. Average pairwise percentage agreement among coders was 92%, and average pairwise Cohen κ was 0.82.
Among the 8871 videos from 97 influencers that made up the final analytical sample, we identified 1360 videos (15.3%) that featured at least one food or beverage product. These 1360 videos were viewed >9 million times and received >1 million likes each. Nearly half (n=648, 47.6%) of the videos featured a branded product. Most videos featuring a branded product did not contain a brand relationship disclosure (n=449, 69.3%). Among videos that disclosed a brand relationship, influencers used 10 different types of disclosures. Tagging a brand in the video's caption was the most common disclosure method (n=182, 28.1%). Six types of caption hashtags were used to disclose brand relationships, including #[brandname] (n=63, 9.7%) and #ad (n=30, 4.6%). Only 1 video (0.2%) made use of TikTok's official disclosure label and only 1 video (0.2%) verbally mentioned a contractual agreement with a brand.
Among the food and beverage videos with disclosures we identified, the most frequently used mechanism-tagging the brand-did not clearly differentiate between sponsored content and the influencer trying to attract a brand or followers who may like that brand. Social media users, particularly adolescents, need clearer, more robust disclosures from influencers to protect against the undue influence of food marketing. These findings may also inform calls for the Children's Food and Beverage Advertising Initiative-the largest self-regulatory pledge to reduce unhealthy food marketing-to include older adolescents, who are heavily targeted by food and beverage companies on social media.
食品和饮料营销对青少年的健康和饮食有着重要影响。食品和饮料公司每年花费数十亿美元用于广告宣传以推广其产品,并且越来越关注社交媒体有影响力的人。有影响力的人对产品的推荐模糊了娱乐与营销之间的界限。
本研究旨在量化TikTok上有影响力的人推广食品和饮料品牌产品的频率,并记录他们在内容中披露品牌关系的方式范围。
我们从美国TikTok上排名前100的有影响力的人中每人收集了截至2022年7月1日发布的多达100个视频,并记录了有关有影响力的人的信息(如关注者数量)和视频信息(如观看次数和点赞数)。对于每个包含食品或饮料产品的视频,我们确定了其主要展示的产品。然后,一组研究助理对每个视频中产品的展示方式(即视频、音频或字幕中)进行编码,对于有品牌的产品,该视频是否伴有任何品牌关系的披露。编码员之间的平均两两百分比一致性为92%,平均两两科恩κ系数为0.82。
在构成最终分析样本的来自97位有影响力的人的8871个视频中,我们识别出1360个视频(15.3%)展示了至少一种食品或饮料产品。这些1360个视频每个的观看次数超过900万次且点赞数超过100万次。近一半(n = 648,47.6%)的视频展示了有品牌的产品。大多数展示有品牌产品的视频未包含品牌关系披露(n = 449,69.3%)。在披露了品牌关系的视频中,有影响力的人使用了10种不同类型的披露方式。在视频字幕中标记品牌是最常见的披露方法(n = 182,28.1%)。使用了六种类型的字幕主题标签来披露品牌关系,包括#[品牌名称](n = 63,9.7%)和#广告(n = 30,4.6%)。只有1个视频(0.2%)使用了TikTok的官方披露标签,只有1个视频(0.2%)口头提及与品牌的合同协议。
在我们识别出的有披露的食品和饮料视频中,最常用的机制——标记品牌——并未明确区分赞助内容与试图吸引品牌或可能喜欢该品牌的关注者的有影响力的人。社交媒体用户,尤其是青少年,需要有影响力的人进行更清晰、更有力的披露,以防范食品营销的不当影响。这些发现也可能为呼吁儿童食品和饮料广告倡议(减少不健康食品营销的最大自我监管承诺)纳入年龄较大的青少年提供依据,食品和饮料公司在社交媒体上大量针对这些青少年。