Cassetti Viola, López-Ruiz María Victoria, Egea-Ronda Ana, Juan Ulpiano Dory Aviñó, Benedé Azagra Carmen Belén
Valencian International University (VIU), Faculty of Health Science, 46002, Valencia, Spain.
CS. Trujillo del Río. UGC. Palma del Río. Distrito Córdoba- Guadalquivir. Servicio Andaluz de Salud. Grupo GICEAP del Instituto de Investigación Biomédica Maimónides (IMIBIC), Spain.
Public Health Pract (Oxf). 2025 Feb 17;9:100595. doi: 10.1016/j.puhip.2025.100595. eCollection 2025 Jun.
Evidence shows that community health promotion projects should be participatory. However, contextual factors affect the ways these projects can be designed and implemented. This article is part of a study to implement evidence-based guidelines to promote community engagement and it describes barriers and facilitators that can influence its implementation.
Qualitative explorative study using semi-structured interviews and interactive workshops in 13 community health promotion projects across Spain.
Data were collected through semi-structured interviews and workshops with 68 participants from core working groups and key stakeholders from 13 community health projects. Descriptive thematic analysis helped identify codes related to barriers and facilitators. Data were then organized in a matrix to identify how each factor influenced each project (content analysis) and to what degree (totally, partially or absent).
Fourteen facilitators were identified, related to internal organization and strategies to work effectively; and seven barriers, related to lack of resources, dependence on external factors and not knowing how to evaluate.
Most of the factors identified are related to the organisation of the project, with no apparent relation with community engagement. This suggests that organisational structures should be prioritise to ensure the quality of community health promotion projects and their continuity, and to enable engagement of community members throughout a project.
有证据表明社区健康促进项目应具有参与性。然而,背景因素会影响这些项目的设计和实施方式。本文是一项实施基于证据的指南以促进社区参与研究的一部分,它描述了可能影响其实施的障碍和促进因素。
在西班牙的13个社区健康促进项目中,采用半结构化访谈和互动式工作坊进行定性探索性研究。
通过与13个社区健康项目的核心工作小组和关键利益相关者的68名参与者进行半结构化访谈和工作坊收集数据。描述性主题分析有助于识别与障碍和促进因素相关的代码。然后将数据整理成矩阵,以确定每个因素如何影响每个项目(内容分析)以及影响程度(完全、部分或不存在)。
确定了14个促进因素,与内部组织和有效工作策略相关;以及7个障碍,与资源缺乏、依赖外部因素和不知道如何评估相关。
所确定的大多数因素与项目的组织有关,与社区参与没有明显关系。这表明应优先考虑组织结构,以确保社区健康促进项目的质量及其连续性,并使社区成员在整个项目中都能参与进来。