Tahura Syeda Sharaban, Shabur Md Abdus, Nuva Tasnuva Jahan
Deaprtment of Mechatronics and Industrial Engineering, Chittagong University of Engineering and Technology, Chattogram, 4349, Bangladesh.
Institute of Leather Engineering and Technology, University of Dhaka, Dhaka, 1209, Bangladesh.
Sci Rep. 2025 Mar 11;15(1):8377. doi: 10.1038/s41598-025-92831-x.
The shift to online learning during the COVID-19 pandemic presented significant challenges and opportunities, particularly in developing nations like Bangladesh, where digital infrastructure is limited. This study compares the effectiveness of online and offline learning for Bangladeshi engineering students using the Best Worst Method (BWM), a robust decision-making tool that simplifies the analysis by focusing on the best and worst criteria, ensuring consistency and accuracy. Eight key factors, including cost, flexibility, learning effectiveness, and technological challenges, were evaluated to identify the distinct strengths and limitations of each learning modality. The findings highlight that online learning is favored for its affordability and adaptability, with cost (25.74%) and flexibility (19.38%) emerging as the highest-priority criteria. In contrast, offline learning is valued for its hands-on practicality and structured environments, where technological challenges (19.25%) and concentration (18.47%) ranked as the most critical factors. Sensitivity analysis confirms the robustness of these rankings, reinforcing the reliability of the results. This research uniquely applies BWM to a resource-constrained educational context, addressing gaps in the literature. Its findings have broader implications for educational policy and resource allocation, providing actionable insights for designing blended learning strategies. By integrating the flexibility of online platforms with the immersive, practical benefits of offline learning, this study proposes a scalable framework for improving learning outcomes in Bangladesh and similar developing regions.
在新冠疫情期间向在线学习的转变带来了重大挑战和机遇,尤其是在像孟加拉国这样数字基础设施有限的发展中国家。本研究使用最佳最差法(BWM)比较了孟加拉国工科学生在线学习和线下学习的效果,这是一种强大的决策工具,通过关注最佳和最差标准简化分析,确保一致性和准确性。评估了包括成本、灵活性、学习效果和技术挑战在内的八个关键因素,以确定每种学习方式的独特优势和局限性。研究结果表明,在线学习因其可承受性和适应性而受到青睐,成本(25.74%)和灵活性(19.38%)成为最高优先级标准。相比之下,线下学习因其实践操作性和结构化环境而受到重视,其中技术挑战(19.25%)和注意力(18.47%)被列为最关键因素。敏感性分析证实了这些排名的稳健性,增强了结果的可靠性。本研究独特地将最佳最差法应用于资源受限的教育背景,填补了文献中的空白。其研究结果对教育政策和资源分配具有更广泛的影响,为设计混合学习策略提供了可操作的见解。通过将在线平台的灵活性与线下学习的沉浸式实践优势相结合,本研究提出了一个可扩展的框架,以提高孟加拉国及类似发展中地区的学习成果。