Veerendra Darshanam, Neredumilli Prasanna Kumar, Mukku Shiva Shanker Reddy
Dept. of Psychiatry, Viswabharathi Medical College and General Hospital, Kurnool, Andhra Pradesh, India.
Dept. of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, Andhra Medical College, Visakhapatnam, Andhra Pradesh, India.
Indian J Psychol Med. 2025 Mar 12:02537176251323561. doi: 10.1177/02537176251323561.
Many laws and acts related to mental health play a vital role in delivery of mental health services for persons with mental illness (PMI). In India, the Mental Health Act of 1987 (MHA, 1987) was replaced with the Mental Healthcare Act, 2017 (MHCA, 2017). However, there were numerous barriers and challenges in the proper implementation of the Act, and there is a paucity of research on the extent of implementation of the new Act. This study assessed the admission patterns of PMI admitted during the transition phase from MHA, 1987 to MHCA, 2017.
A retrospective chart review was done on admissions through the Hon'ble Magistrate's orders and mentally ill prisoners at a tertiary care psychiatric hospital in first four years (2018-2022) after MHCA enactment. Details regarding the admission, legal variables, and clinical variables were taken from case records.
Our study included 354 patients, including 222 (62.7%) admissions through the Hon'ble Magistrate's orders and 132 (37.3%) mentally ill prisoners. Paranoid schizophrenia ( = 162, 52.9%) was the most common diagnosis and modified electroconvulsive therapy was given to 36% ( = 120) of patients. Total 115 (52%) patients were admitted under MHA, 1987, and 38 (17%) were admitted under MHCA, 2017, and no Act was mentioned in the case of 68 patients (30.6%).
This study highlights the extent of change in admissions of PMI after MHCA, 2017 enactment and sheds light on probable barriers for delay in the proper implementation of the Act. Our study emphasized the need for awareness about MHCA for all stakeholders as adherence to the proper procedure is necessary while admitting patients in closed wards and prison wards of the psychiatric facility.
许多与精神健康相关的法律和法案在为精神疾病患者(PMI)提供精神健康服务方面发挥着至关重要的作用。在印度,1987年《精神健康法》(MHA,1987)已被2017年《精神卫生保健法》(MHCA,2017)取代。然而,该法案的正确实施存在诸多障碍和挑战,且关于新法案实施程度的研究匮乏。本研究评估了从MHA,1987到MHCA,2017过渡阶段PMI的入院模式。
对MHCA颁布后的前四年(2018 - 2022年),一家三级护理精神病医院通过尊敬的治安法官命令入院的患者以及精神病囚犯进行了回顾性病历审查。从病例记录中获取了有关入院、法律变量和临床变量的详细信息。
我们的研究纳入了354名患者,其中通过尊敬的治安法官命令入院的有222名(62.7%),精神病囚犯有132名(37.3%)。偏执型精神分裂症(n = 162,52.9%)是最常见的诊断,36%(n = 120)的患者接受了改良电休克治疗。共有115名(52%)患者依据MHA,1987入院,38名(17%)患者依据MHCA,2017入院,68名患者(30.6%)的病例中未提及任何法案。
本研究突出了2017年MHCA颁布后PMI入院情况的变化程度,并揭示了该法案正确实施可能存在延迟的障碍。我们的研究强调所有利益相关者都需要了解MHCA,因为在精神病设施的封闭病房和监狱病房收治患者时,遵循正确程序是必要的。