Tran Dana H, Cohn Randy M, Schiff Adam P, Saraf Shreya M, Rumps Mia V, Mulcahey Mary K
Stritch School of Medicine, Loyola University Chicago, Maywood, Illinois.
Northwell, New Hyde Park, New York.
JB JS Open Access. 2025 Mar 18;10(1). doi: 10.2106/JBJS.OA.24.00182. eCollection 2025 Jan-Mar.
Orthopaedic surgery is one of the most competitive specialties. In 2024, 1,492 medical students applied to 916 orthopaedic surgery first-year training positions. There are no recent data examining trends in the number of away rotations performed by medical students interested in orthopaedic surgery. The purpose of this study was to enhance understanding about the significance of away rotations and home rotations for successfully matching into orthopaedic surgery.
In January 2024, the survey was distributed to orthopaedic surgery postgraduate year 1 (PGY-1) students at programs participating in the Collaborative Orthopaedic Education Research Group (COERG). The survey was distributed in March 2024 to 4th-year medical students who rotated at participating COERG residency programs. Data were collected on away rotations completed, motivations for participating, barriers encountered, and if the respondent matched at a program where they rotated.
Survey responses were collected from 37 of 90 PGY-1 students (41.1%) and 62 of 325 4th-year medical students (19.1%). The study cohort consisted of 99 applicants from the 2023 and 2024 orthopaedic surgery residency match cycles. PGY-1 students and 4th-year medical students completed an average of 3.4 away rotations and applied to an average of 4.4. Eight of 62 4th-year medical students (12.9%) did not match, with their average number of away rotations being 3.75. Of the 91 respondents who matched, 50 (54.9%) matched at an outside program where they rotated during 4th year. Fifteen (16.5%) matched at their home program. Fifteen (16.5%) matched at a program they had no prior exposure to before the residency interview. Six (6.6%) matched at a program with prior exposure and no away rotation. Five (5.5%) matched at a program with geographical ties and no away rotation.
Medical students applying to orthopaedic surgery residency are completing more away rotations than noted in previous studies. Most medical students match at programs where they complete away rotations or their home program, which subsequently increases the importance of where students decide to do rotations and the number they complete.
骨科手术是竞争最为激烈的专科之一。2024年,1492名医学生申请了916个骨科手术第一年培训职位。目前尚无关于有志于骨科手术的医学生在外轮转数量趋势的最新数据。本研究的目的是加深对在外轮转和本校轮转对于成功匹配骨科手术的重要性的理解。
2024年1月,该调查问卷被分发给参与骨科协作教育研究组(COERG)项目的骨科住院医师第一年(PGY-1)学生。2024年3月,该调查问卷被分发给在参与COERG住院医师项目轮转的四年级医学生。收集了关于已完成的外院轮转、参与的动机、遇到的障碍以及受访者是否在其轮转的项目中匹配成功的数据。
从90名PGY-1学生中的37名(41.1%)和325名四年级医学生中的62名(19.1%)收集到了调查问卷回复。研究队列包括来自2023年和2024年骨科住院医师匹配周期的99名申请者。PGY-1学生和四年级医学生平均完成了3.4次外院轮转,平均申请了4.4个项目。62名四年级医学生中有8名(12.9%)未匹配成功,他们的外院轮转平均次数为3.75次。在91名匹配成功的受访者中,50名(54.9%)在四年级时轮转的外院项目中匹配成功。15名(16.5%)在本校项目中匹配成功。15名(16.5%)在住院医师面试前未曾接触过的项目中匹配成功。6名(6.6%)在之前有接触但未进行外院轮转的项目中匹配成功。5名(5. %)在有地域关联但未进行外院轮转的项目中匹配成功。
申请骨科住院医师项目的医学生完成的外院轮转比之前的研究所指出的更多。大多数医学生在他们完成外院轮转的项目或本校项目中匹配成功,这进而增加了学生决定在何处进行轮转以及他们完成的轮转数量的重要性。