Shapiro Justin, Levin Marc, Sunba Saud, Steinberg Emily, Wu Vince, Lee John M
Department of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery, Western University, London, Ontario, Canada.
Department of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
J Neurol Surg B Skull Base. 2024 Apr 15;86(2):185-190. doi: 10.1055/s-0044-1786045. eCollection 2025 Apr.
The use of online teaching modalities to supplement surgical learning has increased recently, demonstrating promising results. Previous studies have analyzed the value and usefulness of YouTube as an educational source to learners, including teaching surgical skills to Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery (OHNS) trainees. YouTube videos on endoscopic sinus surgery (ESS) still need to be explored as ESS remains a common, yet challenging surgery that OHNS residents encounter regularly. This study aimed to objectively evaluate the usefulness of YouTube videos on ESS for surgical education. YouTube was searched using the following keywords: "uncinectomy," "maxillary antrostomy," "anterior ethmoidectomy," and "ethmoid bulla resection." These represent the initial ESS steps residents learn. Each video was assessed for eligibility by two independent reviewers. The LAParoscopic surgery Video Educational Guidelines (LAP-VEGaS) and ESS-specific criteria were used to assess educational quality. Video popularity index (VPI) was used to calculate video popularity. Of the 38 videos that met inclusion criteria, the average LAP-VEGaS score was 6.59 (± ) 3.23 standard deviation. Most videos were designated low quality. There was a weak positive correlation between whether a video included ESS-specific criteria and LAP-VEGaS score ( = 0.269, = 0.102). There was a significant positive correlation between VPI and LAP-VEGaS scores ( = 0.497, = 0.003). Overall, the quality of included videos was poor. OHNS residents should not rely solely or primarily on YouTube videos to learn surgical skills relevant to ESS. To maximize potential of online teaching, high-quality videos should be used to compliment other methods of teaching.
近年来,使用在线教学模式辅助外科学习的情况有所增加,并显示出了良好的效果。此前的研究分析了YouTube作为教育资源对学习者的价值和实用性,包括向耳鼻咽喉-头颈外科(OHNS)实习生传授外科技能。由于内镜鼻窦手术(ESS)仍是OHNS住院医师经常遇到的常见但具有挑战性的手术,因此关于ESS的YouTube视频仍有待探索。本研究旨在客观评估YouTube上ESS视频在外科教育中的实用性。
使用以下关键词在YouTube上进行搜索:“钩突切除术”“上颌窦造口术”“前筛窦切除术”和“筛泡切除术”。这些代表了住院医师学习ESS的初始步骤。由两名独立评审员对每个视频进行合格性评估。
使用腹腔镜手术视频教育指南(LAP-VEGaS)和ESS特定标准来评估教育质量。视频人气指数(VPI)用于计算视频的受欢迎程度。
在符合纳入标准的38个视频中,LAP-VEGaS评分的平均值为6.59(±)3.23标准差。大多数视频被判定为低质量。视频是否包含ESS特定标准与LAP-VEGaS评分之间存在弱正相关(r = 0.269,P = 0.102)。VPI与LAP-VEGaS评分之间存在显著正相关(r = 0.497,P = 0.003)。
总体而言,纳入视频的质量较差。OHNS住院医师不应仅仅或主要依赖YouTube视频来学习与ESS相关的外科技能。为了最大限度地发挥在线教学的潜力,应使用高质量视频来补充其他教学方法。