Cáceres-Rivera Diana Isabel, Ruiz-Sandoval Jessica Paola, Cristancho-Zambrano Luisa Yaneth, Pulido-Montes Maria Andreina, López-Romero Luis Alberto
Enfermera, Magister en Enfermería, Doctora en Biomedicina. Universidad Cooperativa de Colombia. Facultad de Enfermería. Bucaramanga. Colombia. E-mail:
Enfermera. Universidad Cooperativa de Colombia. Facultad de Enfermería. Bucaramanga. Colombia. E-mail:
Rev Cuid. 2023 Mar 31;13(3):e2301. doi: 10.15649/cuidarte.2301. eCollection 2022 Sep-Dec.
Nursing workload in intensive care units (ICUs) is related to efficiency and quality of care; however, there are no methods to quantify the nurses needed per shift in ICUs.
To identify the most used tools to measure ICU nursing workload.
An integrative literature review was performed using original articles in English, Spanish or Portuguese, pub lished between 1991 and 2017 in the databases ScienceDirect, BVS, Scopus, and Embase. The search strategy was "" Duplicate articles or articles about intermediate care units were excluded. The quality of the articles was assessed using the Strobe checklist.
Thirty-six articles with a total of 19,036 patients were included; 50% (n=18) used NAS, 27.7% (n=10) used a combination of methods such as NAS, NEMS, TISS-28 or VACTE; 13.8% (n=5) used TISS-28, 5.6% (n=2) used video camera record ing, and 2.7% (n=1) used NEMS to quantify the time spent by nurses in care.
There is currently no consensus on workload measurement methods in nursing. In this sense, more validation and comparison studies are needed to improve nursing care management in the ICUs.
The most used tool to quantify workload in nursing is the Nursing Activities Score (NAS). Other tools identified were NEMS, TISS-28, and VACTE.
重症监护病房(ICU)的护理工作量与护理效率和质量相关;然而,目前尚无方法可量化ICU每班所需的护士人数。
确定测量ICU护理工作量最常用的工具。
进行一项综合文献综述,使用1991年至2017年期间发表在ScienceDirect、BVS、Scopus和Embase数据库中的英文、西班牙文或葡萄牙文原创文章。检索策略为“……”。重复发表的文章或关于中间护理单元的文章被排除。使用Strobe清单评估文章质量。
纳入36篇文章,共涉及19036例患者;50%(n = 18)使用护理活动评分(NAS),27.7%(n = 10)使用NAS、护理事件监测系统(NEMS)、治疗干预评分系统-28(TISS-28)或视觉模拟连续追踪评价法(VACTE)等多种方法的组合;13.8%(n = 5)使用TISS-28,5.6%(n = 2)使用摄像机记录,2.7%(n = 1)使用NEMS来量化护士护理所花费的时间。
目前在护理工作量测量方法上尚无共识。从这个意义上讲,需要更多的验证和比较研究来改善ICU的护理管理。
护理中最常用的工作量量化工具是护理活动评分(NAS)。其他确定的工具包括NEMS、TISS-28和VACTE。