Koiter Alexander J, Malone Tamaragh Y
Department of Geography & Environment, Brandon University, Brandon, Manitoba, Canada.
Department of Biology, Brandon University, Brandon, Manitoba, Canada.
J Environ Qual. 2025 May-Jun;54(3):634-646. doi: 10.1002/jeq2.70012. Epub 2025 Mar 22.
Riparian areas play an important role in maintaining water quality in agricultural watersheds by buffering sediment, nutrients, and other pollutants. Recent studies have shown that in some cases riparian areas are a net source of phosphorus (P) in cold climates. This study assessed the impact of cattle grazing or harvesting of riparian areas on the spatial and vertical distribution of water-extractable phosphorus (WEP). This study measured the WEP in four distinctive sources: biomass, litter, organic layer, and Ah horizon in three riparian locations extending from the edge of the waterbody to the field edge. In addition to a control, three treatments were examined: (1) grazing; (2) high-density grazing; and (3) mowing. Prior to implementing the treatments, the Ah (0-10 cm) soil was the largest pool of WEP (42.5 mg m, ∼44%); however, the biomass (i.e., standing vegetation) was a considerable proportion of the total (26.3 mg m, ∼25%) WEP pool. The litter and organic layer had median WEP areal densities of 11.1 and 17.7 mg m, respectively. Findings revealed significant reductions in biomass WEP with median reductions of 10.4 and 18.7 mg m for high-density grazing and mowing treatments, respectively. This reduction was more pronounced in the lower riparian locations where there was more biomass available to be grazed or mowed. There were no detectable changes in the other sources of WEP across all the treatments. Assessment of the control plots (pre- and post-treatment) clearly indicates that there is considerable small-scale spatial variability in P measurements in riparian areas. Overall, the results of this study suggest that management practices that target vegetation, including harvesting and short-term autumn grazing, may be mechanisms to reduce the potential P loss during the snowmelt period. To fully assess the risk of P loss, studies investigating other important riparian processes that also have a demonstrated impact on P mobility, including freeze-thaw cycles and flooding, are needed.
河岸带在缓冲沉积物、养分和其他污染物方面对维持农业流域水质起着重要作用。最近的研究表明,在某些情况下,河岸带在寒冷气候下是磷(P)的净来源。本研究评估了河岸带的牛放牧或收割对水溶磷(WEP)空间和垂直分布的影响。本研究测量了四个不同来源的WEP:生物量、凋落物、有机层和三个从水体边缘延伸至田间边缘的河岸位置的腐殖质层。除了一个对照外,还研究了三种处理方式:(1)放牧;(2)高密度放牧;(3)刈割。在实施处理之前,腐殖质层(0 - 10厘米)土壤是WEP的最大储存库(42.5毫克/平方米,约44%);然而,生物量(即现存植被)占WEP总储存库的相当比例(26.3毫克/平方米,约25%)。凋落物和有机层的WEP面密度中位数分别为11.1和17.7毫克/平方米。研究结果显示,生物量中的WEP显著减少,高密度放牧和刈割处理的中位数减少量分别为10.4和18.7毫克/平方米。这种减少在较低的河岸位置更为明显,那里有更多的生物量可供放牧或刈割。在所有处理中,其他WEP来源均未检测到变化。对照样地(处理前后)的评估清楚地表明,河岸带磷测量存在相当大的小尺度空间变异性。总体而言,本研究结果表明,针对植被的管理措施,包括收割和秋季短期放牧,可能是减少融雪期潜在磷流失的机制。为了全面评估磷流失风险,需要开展研究调查其他对磷迁移也有显著影响的重要河岸带过程,包括冻融循环和洪水。