Branitsky Alison, Bowe Samantha, Morrison Anthony P, Longden Eleanor, Bucci Sandra, Mulligan Lee D, Varese Filippo
Division of Psychology and Mental Health, School of Health Sciences, Faculty of Biology, Medicine and Health, Manchester Academic Health Sciences Centre, The University of Manchester, Manchester, M13 9PL, United Kingdom.
Psychosis Research Unit, Greater Manchester Mental Health NHS Foundation Trust, Manchester, M25 3BL, United Kingdom.
Schizophr Bull Open. 2025 Feb 4;6(1):sgaf002. doi: 10.1093/schizbullopen/sgaf002. eCollection 2025 Jan.
User-led hearing voices groups (HVGs) have existed for the past 40 years, but little research has been conducted into if and how this approach can be implemented in statutory mental health settings, and whether they can be delivered effectively when held online. The aim of this study was to conduct a feasibility and acceptability trial of an online HVG for the UK National Health Service (NHS) users who hear voices, to inform a future larger-scale trial.
A mixed-methods, nonrandomized feasibility study of an online HVG was conducted with 9 participants. Participants attended weekly online meetings for 6 months and completed measures of social connectedness, voice hearing, personal recovery, as well as semi-structured interviews, at baseline and postintervention (26-weeks). Primary outcomes were qualitative and quantitative assessments of feasibility and acceptability.
Thirty-eight participants were referred to the trial, 9 of whom were recruited (100% of the target sample). The trial had high retention (100%) and engagement (mean = 13.2 groups attended). Participants reported positive features of attending this digital intervention, with 85% reporting it was helpful to meet other voice hearers, that the group helped them make sense of voice hearing experiences, that they received positive messages about recovery, and that the group represented a form of support they could not get elsewhere.
The findings indicate it is feasible and acceptable to run an online HVG within an NHS setting. A larger trial is needed to further investigate the utility, efficacy, and cost-effectiveness of running online HVGs in the NHS.
ISRCTN11873550.
由用户主导的幻听群体(HVGs)已经存在了40年,但对于这种方法能否以及如何在法定心理健康环境中实施,以及在网上开展时能否有效实施,相关研究甚少。本研究的目的是对面向英国国家医疗服务体系(NHS)幻听患者的在线HVG进行可行性和可接受性试验,为未来更大规模的试验提供依据。
对9名参与者进行了在线HVG的混合方法、非随机可行性研究。参与者参加了为期6个月的每周在线会议,并在基线和干预后(26周)完成了社会联系、幻听、个人康复的测量以及半结构化访谈。主要结果是对可行性和可接受性的定性和定量评估。
38名参与者被推荐参加试验,其中9人被招募(达到目标样本的100%)。该试验具有高保留率(100%)和参与度(平均参加13.2次小组会议)。参与者报告了参加这种数字干预的积极特点,85%的人表示与其他幻听患者见面很有帮助,该小组帮助他们理解幻听经历,他们收到了关于康复的积极信息,并且该小组代表了一种他们在其他地方无法获得的支持形式。
研究结果表明,在NHS环境中开展在线HVG是可行且可接受的。需要进行更大规模的试验,以进一步研究在NHS中开展在线HVG的效用、疗效和成本效益。
ISRCTN11873550。