Leverso John, O'Neill Kate K, Knorre Alex, Mohler George
University of Cincinnati, School of Criminal Justice Department, 2610 University Circle, Cincinnati, OH 45221, United States of America.
University of Iowa, Department of Sociology, North Hall, 401, Iowa City, IA 52242, United States of America.
J Crim Justice. 2025 Jan-Feb;96. doi: 10.1016/j.jcrimjus.2024.102344. Epub 2024 Dec 27.
This study investigates the social network structure of an online gang forum, focusing on the social location of gang-affiliated girls and women in the "digital streets." Existing studies highlight how gang members use social media for masculine posturing and promoting violent identities, but there is a significant gap in understanding the digital engagement of girls and women in gangs. Specifically, few studies have directly examined the network positionality of girls and women through social network analysis of digital data. Our research addresses this gap by analyzing user-to-user interactions on a public Facebook page popular among Chicago-area gang members, circa 2015-2016 (4231 positive and negative interactions across 37,403 comments from 6829 user profiles). Digital platforms could offer a space where girls and women who claim gang affiliation can be liberated from analog constraints in establishing gang centrality. Findings indicate, however, that girls and women remain in peripheral network positions, undermining the liberation hypothesis. Our findings challenge optimistic narratives about the liberating potential of social media, underscore the persistence of misogyny in gang culture, and contribute to understanding how digitalization affects gang dynamics.
本研究调查了一个在线帮派论坛的社会网络结构,重点关注与帮派有关联的女孩和女性在“数字街道”中的社会位置。现有研究强调了帮派成员如何利用社交媒体进行男性姿态展示和宣扬暴力身份,但在理解女孩和女性在帮派中的数字参与方面存在重大差距。具体而言,很少有研究通过对数字数据的社会网络分析直接考察女孩和女性的网络位置。我们的研究通过分析一个在2015 - 2016年左右受芝加哥地区帮派成员欢迎的公共脸书页面上的用户对用户互动来填补这一差距(来自6829个用户资料的37403条评论中的4231条正负互动)。数字平台可能提供了一个空间,让那些声称与帮派有关联 的女孩和女性在确立帮派核心地位时能够摆脱传统限制。然而,研究结果表明,女孩和女性仍处于网络边缘位置,这削弱了解放假设。我们的研究结果挑战了关于社交媒体解放潜力的乐观说法,强调了帮派文化中厌女症的持续存在,并有助于理解数字化如何影响帮派动态。