Critical periods during development as assessed by thallium-induced inhibition of growth of embryonic chick tibiae in vitro.

In ovo application of thallium sulfate has been shown to produce a characteristic shortening and angulation of the tibia of the embryonic chick. The critical period for susceptibility to thallium-induced inhibition of tibial growth ends at 8 2/3 days of incubation, a time when the growth rate of the embryo declines by 55%. The aim of the present study was to expose tibiae to thallium in vitro to determine whether this response was intrinsic to the tibia. A 4-hour exposure to 400 micrograms thallium was found to be most effective. Growth of tibiae from 8-day-old embryos was inhibited, growth of tibiae from 9-day-old embryos was not, and the response of tibiae isolated from embryos of 8 2/3 days of incubation was intermediate. Therefore, the response of the tibia to thallium represents an intrinsic property and is not secondary to inhibited nerve growth as has been suggested. The critical period and its termination is also an intrinsic property of the tibia. Tibiae were exposed to thallium for 4 hours at various times after the tibiae had been established in vitro. Susceptibility to growth inhibition was shown to decline as tibiae developed beyond the critical period, a decline that could be correlated with a declining growth rate. Emphasis is placed upon critical events during development as a more useful concept than critical periods for explaining susceptibility to teratogens.