Tan Ren Hao Linus, Goff Anthony J, Lim Chien Joo, Tan Yijia Bryan
Physiotherapy Department, Sengkang General Hospital, 110 Sengkang East Way, Singapore, 544886, Singapore.
Health and Social Sciences, Singapore Institute of Technology, 10 Dover Drive, Singapore, 138683, Singapore.
BMC Musculoskelet Disord. 2025 Mar 26;26(1):298. doi: 10.1186/s12891-025-08524-z.
The aim of this study was to assess the self-reported quality of care for people with knee osteoarthritis in Singapore and to investigate the associations between participant characteristics and functional outcomes at 1 year in relation to the reported quality of care.
Patients with knee osteoarthritis completed the osteoarthritis quality indicator (OA-QI) questionnaire, a validated patient-reported measure that assesses the clinician's adherence to evidence-based guidelines for non-surgical knee osteoarthritis education and patient education. The OA-QI includes 17 indicators, with "achievement" defined as a 'Yes' response for each. We calculated individual per-item, overall per-item mean, and per-person achievement rates (%) and examined associations between participant characteristics, achievement rates, and function at 1 year.
A total of 314 participants completed the OA-QI. Referral for physical activity (87.5%) and referral for daily activity aid assessment (15.7%) had the highest and lowest per-item achievement rates, respectively. The overall mean per-item and per-person achievement rates were both 62.2%. Participants educated about steroid injections (adjusted coefficient [95% CI]: 7.23 [1.42-13.04]; p = 0.015) or surgery (adjusted coefficient [95% CI]: 12.65 [5.89-19.40]; p < 0.001) had worse functional outcomes at one year than those who were eligible but not informed. Those not assessed for walking aids and indicating walking issues had poorer outcomes one year later (adjusted coefficient [95% CI]: -9.89 (-19.63, -0.15); p = 0.0470). However, no significant associations were found between per-person achievement rates and 1-year functional outcomes.
The quality of care in Singapore for people with knee osteoarthritis is suboptimal, especially for those needing walking aids and weight loss assistance. However, the quality of care alone does not fully account for long-term outcomes, suggesting that other factors need to be considered.
本研究旨在评估新加坡膝骨关节炎患者自我报告的护理质量,并调查参与者特征与1年时功能结局之间的关联,这些关联与报告的护理质量有关。
膝骨关节炎患者完成了骨关节炎质量指标(OA-QI)问卷,这是一种经过验证的患者报告测量工具,用于评估临床医生对非手术膝骨关节炎教育和患者教育的循证指南的遵循情况。OA-QI包括17项指标,每项指标的“达成情况”定义为回答“是”。我们计算了各项指标的个体达成率、总体平均达成率和每人达成率(%),并研究了参与者特征、达成率和1年时功能之间的关联。
共有314名参与者完成了OA-QI。体育活动转诊(87.5%)和日常活动辅助评估转诊(15.7%)的单项达成率分别最高和最低。总体平均每项指标达成率和每人达成率均为62.2%。接受过类固醇注射教育(调整系数[95%置信区间]:7.23[1.42 - 13.04];p = 0.015)或手术教育(调整系数[95%置信区间]:12.65[5.89 - 19.40];p < 0.001)的参与者在1年时的功能结局比符合条件但未被告知的参与者更差。未接受助行器评估且表示有行走问题的参与者在1年后结局更差(调整系数[95%置信区间]:-9.89(-19.63,-0.15);p = 0.0470)。然而,未发现每人达成率与1年时功能结局之间存在显著关联。
新加坡对膝骨关节炎患者的护理质量欠佳,尤其是对那些需要助行器和体重减轻帮助的患者。然而,仅护理质量并不能完全解释长期结局,这表明还需要考虑其他因素。