Bottaccioli Anna Giulia, Bologna Mauro, Bottaccioli Francesco
Department of Oncohematology, Clinical Psychology Graduated Course, University of Milan, I-20122 Milan, Italy.
Società Italiana di Psiconeuroendocrinoimmunologia, I-00195 Rome, Italy.
Int J Mol Sci. 2025 Mar 19;26(6):2759. doi: 10.3390/ijms26062759.
It is known that the effectiveness of drug treatment for depression, ammine deficit based, is largely unsatisfactory. In this review, we examine the proposal of a precision therapy has emerged and has received a strong push by the identification of the role of inflammation in depression. However, precision psychiatry risks being caught in the reductionist trap of searching for the molecular switch that resets the whole system and switches off the disease. This is an illusion since the human being is complex and depression is a systemic and variable disorder. In this study, we show the inadequacy of the reductionist paradigm, and, at the same time, illustrate the superiority of the systemic paradigm centered on psychoneuroendocrineimmunology (PNEI). According to the PNEI paradigm, depression is a disease of the whole human being, caused by different sources working together: psychological, biological, and behavioral. This means knowing the biological and psychological history of the subject, identifying relational and biological crisis factors, and building personalized treatments targeting those factors with the tools of medicine and psychology, which are not reducible to the combination of drugs and psychotherapy. Our proposal presents a paradigm shift that is both theoretical and practical, which enables clinicians to assess patients experiencing depression in a unified way and treat them in an integrated manner.
众所周知,基于胺缺乏的抑郁症药物治疗效果在很大程度上并不理想。在这篇综述中,我们探讨了一种精准治疗方案的提出,该方案因炎症在抑郁症中的作用被确定而得到了有力推动。然而,精准精神病学有可能陷入还原论的陷阱,即寻找重置整个系统并消除疾病的分子开关。这是一种错觉,因为人类是复杂的,抑郁症是一种系统性且多变的疾病。在本研究中,我们展示了还原论范式的不足,同时说明了以心理神经内分泌免疫学(PNEI)为核心的系统范式的优越性。根据PNEI范式,抑郁症是一种由多种因素共同作用导致的全身性疾病:心理、生物和行为因素。这意味着要了解患者的生物和心理病史,识别关系和生物危机因素,并运用医学和心理学工具针对这些因素制定个性化治疗方案,而不能简单归结为药物和心理治疗的组合。我们的提议代表了一种理论和实践上的范式转变,使临床医生能够以统一的方式评估抑郁症患者,并以综合的方式进行治疗。