Itani Mohammad S, Shankar Megha, Goldstein Ellen
Hariri School of Nursing, American University of Beirut, Bliss Street, Hamra, Beirut, Lebanon.
Division of General Internal Medicine, Department of Medicine, University of California San Diego, San Diego, CA, USA.
BMC Health Serv Res. 2025 Mar 27;25(1):452. doi: 10.1186/s12913-025-12519-w.
There are no existing standards of care for integrating trauma-informed care into prenatal care in a patient-centered manner. This study aims to explore preferences of pregnant people regarding prenatal care, prenatal providers, resources, and trauma inquiry and response.
This study utilized a qualitative descriptive design as part of a longitudinal randomized controlled pilot trial. It was conducted at a university-affiliated federally qualified health center and multi-specialty clinic in a large metropolitan area among a purposive sample of 27 racially/ethnically diverse pregnant individuals. Eligible participants aged ≥ 18 between 10 and 24 weeks gestation were identified via medical charts and recruited in person and by email. Interview-administered structured interviews were provided at the post-intervention assessment. Qualitative data collection extended from June 2023 through April 2024. We performed inductive analysis to generate codes and identify emergent themes derived from participant responses. Participant preferences for prenatal care were interpreted through the lens of the six trauma-informed care principles.
Participants had an average age of (M = 28, SD = 4.5; range = 19-38) years old. Of the 27 participants interviewed, 21 self-identified as Black (77.8%) and 5 as Hispanic (18.5%). Three themes identified optimal prenatal care preferences, including: (1) Agency and Choice; (2) Emphasis on Maternal and Child health and Wellbeing; and (3) Universal and Personalized Provision of Information and Resources. Participants wanted their providers to be Familiar and Experienced; Personally Engaging; and Emotionally Safe and Supportive. Three additional themes focused on patient preferences for addressing trauma during prenatal visits, including: (1) Value of Addressing Trauma; (2) Approaches to Asking about Trauma; and (3) Sensitive and Empathic Inquiry and Response.
Patient preferences identified by this study underscore the need for prenatal care to address the psychological health needs of pregnant patients to deliver high quality, comprehensive prenatal care that is trauma-informed and culturally-responsive.
This study was registered at ClinicalTrials.gov ID: NCT05718479 on 08-02-2023.
目前尚无将创伤知情照护以患者为中心的方式纳入产前护理的现有照护标准。本研究旨在探讨孕妇在产前护理、产前护理提供者、资源以及创伤询问与应对方面的偏好。
本研究采用定性描述性设计,作为一项纵向随机对照试验的一部分。研究在一个大城市地区的大学附属联邦合格健康中心和多专科诊所进行,选取了27名种族/民族多样化的孕妇作为有目的的样本。通过病历识别出符合条件的妊娠10至24周、年龄≥18岁的参与者,并通过面对面和电子邮件的方式招募。在干预后评估时进行访谈式结构化访谈。定性数据收集从2023年6月持续到2024年4月。我们进行归纳分析以生成编码,并识别从参与者回答中得出的新出现的主题。通过六项创伤知情照护原则来解读参与者对产前护理的偏好。
参与者的平均年龄为(M = 28,SD = 4.5;范围 = 19 - 38)岁。在接受访谈的27名参与者中,21人自我认定为黑人(77.8%),5人认定为西班牙裔(18.5%)。确定了三个主题来描述最佳产前护理偏好,包括:(1)自主性与选择;(2)强调母婴健康与福祉;(3)信息与资源的普遍提供和个性化提供。参与者希望他们的护理提供者熟悉且经验丰富;能建立个人联系;在情感上感到安全且给予支持。另外三个主题聚焦于患者在产前检查期间处理创伤的偏好,包括:(1)处理创伤的价值;(2)询问创伤的方式;(3)敏感且共情的询问与回应。
本研究确定的患者偏好强调了产前护理需要满足孕妇的心理健康需求,以提供高质量、全面的、具有创伤知情且文化适应性的产前护理。
本研究于2023年8月2日在ClinicalTrials.gov注册,标识符为NCT05718479。