Sun Qi, Tian Jingjun, Lu Wenlin, Zhang Jun, Yin Zhangcheng, Yao Lan, Zou Xinchun, Li Baofan, Li Yanhong, Liu Juan
Department of Preventive Dentistry, Kunming Medical University School and Hospital of Stomatology, Kunming, 650106, China.
Yunnan Key Laboratory of Stomatology, Kunming, 650106, China.
BMC Oral Health. 2025 Apr 1;25(1):466. doi: 10.1186/s12903-025-05839-0.
This study aimed to analyze the efficiency of oral health resource allocation in public medical institutions in Yunnan Province at the end of the 13th Five-Year Plan period in China. The findings will provide a theoretical basis for the government and health administration departments to formulate regional medical and health plans and adjust policies and systems. Additionally, tailored recommendations will be proposed to optimize the allocation of oral health resources in public medical institutions in Yunnan Province and enhance resource utilization efficiency.
The present investigation scrutinizes the prevailing distribution of oral health resources within public institutions situated in Yunnan Province, marking the culmination of the 13th Five-Year Plan era. Employing cross-sectional analysis, the study utilizes conventional BCC and CCR models of Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA), alongside the super-efficiency SBM model, to assess the efficacy of resource allocation across 16 prefectures (or cities) within the province.
In the conventional model analysis, the average technical efficiency (TE) of oral health resource allocation in 16 prefectures (or cities) of Yunnan Province at the end of the 13th Five-Year Plan was 0.867, with an average pure technical efficiency (PTE) of 0.914 and an average scale efficiency (SE) of 0.950. Out of the 16 decision-making entities, 2 exhibit effectiveness according to DEA standards, 2 demonstrate weak effectiveness, while 9 manifest ineffectiveness. In the SBM super-efficiency model analysis, the TE of the whole province was 0.820, accompanied by an average PTE of 1.110 and an average SE of 0.863. Five prefectures (or cities) attained super-efficiency effectiveness, with Kunming City (the provincial capital of Yunnan) distinguishing itself notably owing to substantial disparities in PTE (3.840) and SE (0.293).
On the whole, the efficacy in leveraging oral health resources within public medical institutions throughout Yunnan Province was deemed relatively commendable. Nonetheless, notable disparities among prefectures (or cities) persisted, characterized by an excessive concentration of premium resources. Ineffective resource utilization coexisted with inadequate distribution. It is recommended to customize the distribution of oral health resources in each area according to local conditions, facilitate the decentralization of premium resources, and enhance the capacity of oral medical services.
本研究旨在分析“十三五”规划期末中国云南省公立医疗机构口腔卫生资源配置效率。研究结果将为政府和卫生行政部门制定区域医疗卫生规划、调整政策和制度提供理论依据。此外,还将提出针对性建议,以优化云南省公立医疗机构口腔卫生资源配置,提高资源利用效率。
本次调查审视了“十三五”规划期末云南省公立机构口腔卫生资源的现有分布情况。该研究采用横断面分析方法,运用数据包络分析(DEA)的传统BCC和CCR模型以及超效率SBM模型,评估全省16个州(市)的资源配置效率。
在传统模型分析中,“十三五”规划期末云南省16个州(市)口腔卫生资源配置的平均技术效率(TE)为0.867,平均纯技术效率(PTE)为0.914,平均规模效率(SE)为0.950。在16个决策实体中,根据DEA标准,2个表现有效,2个表现为弱有效,9个表现无效。在SBM超效率模型分析中,全省的TE为0.820,平均PTE为1.110,平均SE为0.863。5个州(市)达到超效率有效,其中昆明市(云南省省会)因PTE(3.840)和SE(0.293)存在显著差异而格外突出。
总体而言,云南省公立医疗机构在利用口腔卫生资源方面的效率被认为相对值得称赞。然而,州(市)之间仍存在显著差异,表现为优质资源过度集中。资源利用无效与分布不均并存。建议根据当地情况定制各地区口腔卫生资源的分配,促进优质资源的分散,并提高口腔医疗服务能力。