Güneyli Ayşegül, Begall Katia, Verbakel Ellen
Radboud University, Department of Sociology, Thomas van Aquinostraat 4, Nijmegen 6525 GD, the Netherlands.
Adv Life Course Res. 2025 Jun;64:100671. doi: 10.1016/j.alcr.2025.100671. Epub 2025 Mar 22.
Unpaid caregiving remains highly gendered both in the context of childcare for young children and informal care provided to ill or ageing family members, friends, or neighbors. Using a life-course framework, this study expands previous research which generally treated these care types as separate life domains, by exploring the variety in caregiving trajectories including both childcare and informal care as integral parts of life courses. In addition to identifying and describing clusters of caregiving trajectories, we examine to what extent these are stratified by gender and education. We use unique retrospective survey data on informal caregiving combined with longitudinal data on childrearing, collected by the LISS Panel in the Netherlands (N = 1631). Using sequence and cluster analysis, we created caregiving trajectories covering up to 50 years of individual life courses and identified six clusters of caregiving trajectories that differed in care-heaviness, based on different combinations of the timing, duration, order, and intensity of care episodes. Our findings indicate path-dependency in care patterns, whereby most individuals who have engaged in unpaid care, provided both childcare and informal care at various points throughout their lives. In addition, while patterns of caregiving over the life course did not differ by gender, women were overrepresented in care-heavier clusters while men were more likely to follow the least care-heavy clusters. Theoretical expectations predicting educational differences based on opportunity costs and normative pressure were not supported. Given the anticipated rise in informal care due to population ageing and welfare state retrenchment, our findings suggest that while both women and men will be increasingly confronted with balancing unpaid care with other commitments, the gender gap in care-heaviness might persist and even widen.
在照顾幼儿以及为生病或年迈的家庭成员、朋友或邻居提供非正式照料方面,无偿照护工作的性别差异仍然非常明显。本研究采用生命历程框架,拓展了以往的研究,以往研究通常将这些照护类型视为不同的生活领域,而本研究通过探索照护轨迹的多样性,将儿童照料和非正式照料视为生命历程的组成部分。除了识别和描述照护轨迹的类别,我们还考察了这些轨迹在性别和教育方面的分层程度。我们使用了荷兰LISS小组收集的关于非正式照护的独特回顾性调查数据以及关于育儿的纵向数据(N = 1631)。通过序列和聚类分析,我们创建了涵盖个人生命历程长达50年的照护轨迹,并根据照护事件的时间、持续时间、顺序和强度的不同组合,识别出了六个在照护负担上有所不同的照护轨迹类别。我们的研究结果表明照护模式存在路径依赖,即大多数从事无偿照护的人在其一生中的不同阶段既提供儿童照料又提供非正式照料。此外,虽然生命历程中的照护模式在性别上没有差异,但在照护负担较重的类别中女性占比过高,而男性更有可能处于照护负担最轻的类别。基于机会成本和规范压力预测教育差异的理论预期未得到支持。鉴于人口老龄化和福利国家紧缩预计会导致非正式照护需求增加,我们的研究结果表明,虽然男性和女性都将越来越面临平衡无偿照护与其他责任的问题,但照护负担方面的性别差距可能会持续甚至扩大。