Robinson Delbert G, Schooler Nina R, John Majnu, Cahill John Daniel, Gonzalez Cristina Gomes, Marcy Patricia, Adams Catherine, Distasio Mary, Gerber Carla, Hackett Brienne, Nunez Maria Sanchez, Srihari Vinod H, Kane John M
The Donald and Barbara Zucker School of Medicine at Hofstra/Northwell, Departments of Psychiatry and of Molecular Medicine, Hempstead, NY, USA; The Feinstein Institutes for Medical Research, Institute of Behavioral Science, Manhasset, NY, USA; The Zucker Hillside Hospital, Psychiatry Research, Northwell Health System, Glen Oaks, NY, USA.
SUNY Downstate Medical Center, Department of Psychiatry, Brooklyn, NY, USA.
Schizophr Res. 2025 May;279:79-86. doi: 10.1016/j.schres.2025.03.021. Epub 2025 Apr 2.
A Learning Health System (LHS) requires data to improve care.
Data are from the ESPRITO LHS that includes 13 US clinics providing coordinated specialty care (CSC) for first-episode psychosis. Causes of missing data examined were: clinic patients not enrolling in ESPRITO, participants prematurely disengaging from treatment and missing patient-reported outcomes.
ESPRITO informed consent used a verbal opt-out format. This resulted in a high participant agreement rate (83.5 %) but limitations on data sharing within ESPRITO. During a 6-month period, 15.4 % of ESPRITO participants prematurely terminated treatment. An exploratory analysis revealed factors associated with increased premature termination likelihood: being homeless or having unstable housing, not being prescribed a long-acting injectable antipsychotic and factors associated with decreased premature termination likelihood: having commercial insurance, longer duration of CSC treatment, better scores on the Global Functioning: Social Scale and reporting higher likelihood to attend on the Intent to Attend scale. Examining patient-reported outcomes, rates of missing data with participants still in treatment on the Questionnaire about the Process of Recovery were 26.5 % at first major assessment rising up to 59.8 % on later assessments.
Missing data are a substantial problem for first-episode psychosis-focused LHS. LHS designs should consider factors that may influence LHS data participation and a LHS research priority should be developing interventions to decrease missing data. LHS data analyses should also consider potential differential characteristics of individuals who are versus who are not included in LHS data sets.
学习型健康系统(LHS)需要数据来改善医疗服务。
数据来自ESPRITO LHS,该系统包括13家美国诊所,为首发精神病患者提供协调专科护理(CSC)。所研究的缺失数据原因包括:诊所患者未加入ESPRITO、参与者过早退出治疗以及患者报告结局缺失。
ESPRITO知情同意采用口头退出格式。这导致了较高的参与者同意率(83.5%),但限制了ESPRITO内部的数据共享。在6个月期间,15.4%的ESPRITO参与者过早终止治疗。一项探索性分析揭示了与过早终止可能性增加相关的因素:无家可归或住房不稳定、未被开具长效注射用抗精神病药物,以及与过早终止可能性降低相关的因素:拥有商业保险、CSC治疗时间较长、在全球功能:社会量表上得分较高以及在参加意愿量表上报告参加可能性较高。在检查患者报告结局时,仍在接受治疗的参与者在首次主要评估时关于康复过程问卷的缺失数据率为26.5%,在后续评估中上升至59.8%。
缺失数据是专注于首发精神病的LHS的一个重大问题。LHS设计应考虑可能影响LHS数据参与的因素,LHS的一项研究重点应是开发减少缺失数据的干预措施。LHS数据分析还应考虑LHS数据集中包含和未包含的个体的潜在差异特征。