Azuma T
Nihon Seikeigeka Gakkai Zasshi. 1985 Mar;59(3):269-83.
The author analysed the radiological results of eighty-three total hip replacements in the patients with severely defective acetabulum secondary to congenital hip dysplasias or failed total hip replacements, after an average follow-up period of three years, paying particular attention to socket loosening. The patients with congenital hip dysplasias were divided into the following four groups: Group 1: The sockets were placed above the level of true acetabulum. Group 2: The sockets were placed in the true acetabulum with the cement used as a filler superolaterally. Group 3: The sockets were placed in the true acetabulum with bone grafts. Group 4: Eccentric sockets were placed in the true acetabulum. The incidence of radiological loosening of the socket was 50% in the group 1, 13% in the group 2, 6% in the group 3 and 75% in the group 4. The patients who underwent revision for socket loosening were also divided into two groups, the one whose acetabula were reconstructed with bone grafts and the other without bone graft. The incidence of radiological loosening of the socket was 28% in the group with bone grafts and 72% in the group without bone graft. The major factor that may have been responsible for socket loosening in these cases was considered to be poor mechanical condition around the socket due to bone deficiency. Two-dimensional finite element analysis was performed to establish the stresses in the periacetabular region after total hip replacement for acetabular deficiency. Model variations include, the conventional plastic socket of 44 mm outside, 28 mm inside diameter placed in false acetabulum or in high level, (2) in true acetabulum using bone cement as a filler, (3) in true acetabulum with bone graft and (4) eccentric socket placed in true acetabulum without bone graft. The ratio of von Mises stress to yield stress of each element were calculated. The results demonstrated that in the periacetabular region, the area superomedial to the socket was at high risk in each model. The area in periacetabular bone where the ratio of von Mises stress to yield stress was more than 20% was almost the same in model (1), (2), (4) and about a half of them in model (3). In conclusion, the most effective method to prevent the socket loosening after total hip replacement in the patient with deficient acetabulum was considered to reconstruct the new spherical acetabulum at anatomical position with bone graft.
作者分析了83例先天性髋关节发育不良或全髋关节置换失败继发严重髋臼缺损患者行全髋关节置换后的放射学结果,平均随访期为3年,特别关注髋臼杯松动情况。先天性髋关节发育不良患者分为以下四组:第1组:髋臼杯置于真髋臼水平之上;第2组:髋臼杯置于真髋臼,用骨水泥作为上外侧填充物;第3组:髋臼杯置于真髋臼并植骨;第4组:偏心髋臼杯置于真髋臼。髋臼杯放射学松动发生率在第1组为50%,第2组为13%,第3组为6%,第4组为75%。因髋臼杯松动而行翻修手术的患者也分为两组,一组髋臼用植骨重建,另一组未植骨。髋臼杯放射学松动发生率在植骨组为28%,未植骨组为72%。这些病例中导致髋臼杯松动的主要因素被认为是由于骨量不足,髋臼杯周围力学条件差。进行二维有限元分析以确定髋臼缺损行全髋关节置换后髋臼周围区域的应力。模型变化包括:(1)外径44mm、内径28mm的传统塑料髋臼杯置于假髋臼或高位;(2)在真髋臼使用骨水泥作为填充物;(3)在真髋臼植骨;(4)偏心髋臼杯置于真髋臼且未植骨。计算每个单元的冯·米塞斯应力与屈服应力之比。结果表明,在髋臼周围区域,各模型中髋臼杯上内侧区域风险较高。髋臼周围骨中冯·米塞斯应力与屈服应力之比超过20%的区域在模型(1)、(2)、(4)中几乎相同,在模型(3)中约为它们的一半。总之,对于髋臼缺损患者,全髋关节置换后预防髋臼杯松动最有效的方法被认为是用植骨在解剖位置重建新的球形髋臼。