AboJabel Hanan, Abo-Rass Fareeda
The Paul Baerwald School of Social Work and Social Welfare, The Hebrew University of Jerusalem, Jerusalem, Israel.
Takemi Program in International Health, Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health, Boston, MA, USA.
J Bioeth Inq. 2025 Apr 9. doi: 10.1007/s11673-024-10414-3.
Older people are often cared for by family caregivers who may experience a variety of challenges. Robots may be helpful. Understanding the attitudes of family caregivers in this context is essential as they are a major factor in robot use. To date, most studies on family caregivers ' attitudes toward robot assistance in elder care have been conducted in East Asian or Western societies, but as such perceptions are affected by culture, in the present study, we investigated the attitudes of Arab family caregivers in Israel. Semi-structured interviews were conducted with twenty Arab family caregivers who provide care to ADL (activities of daily living)-dependent older people. All participants were Muslim and adult children of a person requiring care. The majority (75 per cent) were women, and the average age was fifty-one. Analysis of the interviews revealed two main themes: (1) Attitudes: Most participants strongly objected to the assistance of a robot in caring for older people, and perceived it as a violation of family values; and (2) Reasons for attitudes: Participants preferred human care over robot care due to concerns previously documented among other populations regarding system malfunctions, the risk of loneliness, and lack of technological literacy. We also identified a unique factor: the family 's moral obligation to care for older people. The absolute opposition of family members to the use of a robot in the care of older people requires the development of intervention programmes to increase technological literacy among family caregivers and reduce negative attitudes. These programmes need to address the opportunities and risks associated with the use of robots, and how these risks can be avoided.
老年人通常由家庭照顾者照料,这些照顾者可能会面临各种挑战。机器人或许会有所帮助。了解在这种背景下家庭照顾者的态度至关重要,因为他们是机器人使用的一个主要因素。迄今为止,大多数关于家庭照顾者对机器人辅助老年人护理态度的研究是在东亚或西方社会进行的,但由于这种认知受文化影响,在本研究中,我们调查了以色列阿拉伯家庭照顾者的态度。我们对二十名照顾日常生活依赖他人的老年人的阿拉伯家庭照顾者进行了半结构化访谈。所有参与者都是穆斯林,且是需要照顾者的成年子女。大多数(75%)是女性,平均年龄为51岁。访谈分析揭示了两个主要主题:(1)态度:大多数参与者强烈反对机器人协助照顾老年人,并将其视为对家庭价值观的侵犯;(2)态度的原因:由于此前在其他人群中记录的对系统故障、孤独风险和缺乏技术素养的担忧,参与者更喜欢人力照顾而非机器人照顾。我们还确定了一个独特因素:家庭照顾老年人的道德义务。家庭成员对在照顾老年人中使用机器人的绝对反对,要求制定干预计划,以提高家庭照顾者的技术素养并减少负面态度。这些计划需要解决与使用机器人相关的机遇和风险,以及如何避免这些风险。