Kenzaka Tsuneaki, Yahata Shinsuke, Mizutani Naoya, Kumabe Ayako, Fujiwara Ryo, Kosami Koki, Mori Hiroyuki
Department of Internal Medicine, Hyogo Prefectural Tamba Medical Center, Tamba, JPN.
Division of Community Medicine and Career Development, Kobe University Graduate School of Medicine, Kobe, JPN.
Cureus. 2025 Apr 7;17(4):e81857. doi: 10.7759/cureus.81857. eCollection 2025 Apr.
This study examined the barriers to writing case reports among Japanese physicians who participated in a web study series titled "Let's Write a Case Report! What you need to do to be Accepted" and explored differences in these barriers based on physicians' years of experience.
The study design was cross-sectional in nature. Throughout August and November 2020, the respondents participated in the web study sessions. Using an 11-point scale, from -5 (not a barrier at all) to 0 (neither) to 5 (very much of a barrier), the 16 items interrogated which elements could be barriers to case report writing. Participants were divided into two groups: those with 10 or fewer years of postgraduation experience and those with 11 or more years of postgraduation experience. The basic attributes and possible barriers were compared between the groups using chi-squared and t-tests.
In total, 53 (62.4%) participants responded to the web-based questionnaire. In a comparison between the two groups, the following barriers were significantly higher in the 10 years or fewer group: having sufficient medical documentation to write a report, knowing how to write a case report, determining the main case points and clinical message, knowing how to search the literature, knowing how to obtain literature, meeting the financial cost of accessing literature. Although there were no significant differences, only the lack of motivation to write papers was perceived as a barrier by the 11 years or more group.
Determining the main case points and clinical message, selecting an appropriate journal for submission, and having adequate time to write a paper were the major barriers to writing a case report. Paper-writing motivation was crucial for those with longer clinical experience and experience in writing papers. These barriers were significantly more pronounced among those with fewer than 10 years of clinical experience than among those with 11 or more years of experience. Providing targeted support in developing case points and clinical messages will lead to an increase in the rate of case report writing.
本研究调查了参与名为“让我们撰写病例报告!被录用所需做的事情”网络学习系列的日本医生在撰写病例报告时所面临的障碍,并探讨了基于医生工作年限的这些障碍的差异。
本研究设计为横断面研究。在2020年8月至11月期间,受访者参加了网络学习课程。使用从-5(完全不是障碍)到0(既不是障碍也不是促进因素)到5(非常大的障碍)的11点量表,16个项目询问了哪些因素可能成为病例报告撰写的障碍。参与者分为两组:毕业后工作经验10年及以下的医生和毕业后工作经验11年及以上的医生。使用卡方检验和t检验比较两组之间的基本属性和可能的障碍。
共有53名(62.4%)参与者回复了基于网络的问卷。在两组比较中,以下障碍在工作10年及以下组中显著更高:有足够的医疗记录来撰写报告、知道如何撰写病例报告、确定主要病例要点和临床信息、知道如何检索文献、知道如何获取文献、承担获取文献的财务成本。虽然没有显著差异,但只有缺乏撰写论文的动力被工作11年及以上组视为障碍。
确定主要病例要点和临床信息、选择合适的期刊投稿以及有足够的时间撰写论文是撰写病例报告的主要障碍。论文撰写动力对于临床经验较长且有论文撰写经验的人至关重要。这些障碍在临床经验少于10年的医生中比在11年及以上经验的医生中明显更突出。在制定病例要点和临床信息方面提供有针对性的支持将导致病例报告撰写率的提高。