Piemonti Lorenzo
Unit of Regenerative Medicine and Organ Transplants, IRCCS Ospedale San Raffaele, Milan, Italy.
Università Vita-Salute San Raffaele, Milan, Italy.
Transpl Int. 2025 Apr 1;38:14565. doi: 10.3389/ti.2025.14565. eCollection 2025.
Beta cell replacement therapy for type 1 diabetes (T1D) is undergoing a transformative shift, driven by advances in stem cell biology, gene editing, and tissue engineering. While islet transplantation has demonstrated proof-of-concept success in restoring endogenous insulin production, its clinical impact remains limited by donor scarcity, immune rejection, and procedural complexities. The emergence of stem cell-derived beta-like cells represents a paradigm shift, with initial clinical trials showing promising insulin secretion . However, translating these breakthroughs into scalable, widely accessible treatments poses significant challenges. Drawing parallels to space exploration, this paper argues that while scientific feasibility has been demonstrated, true accessibility remains elusive. Without a strategic shift, beta cell therapy risks becoming an elite intervention, restricted by cost and infrastructure. Lessons from gene and cell therapies for rare diseases highlight the dangers of unsustainable pricing and limited market viability. To bridge the "last mile" a Quality by Design approach is proposed, emphasizing scalability, ease of use, and economic feasibility from the outset. By emphasizing practical implementation over academic achievements, corporate interests, market economics, or patent constraints, beta cell therapy can progress from proof-of-concept to a viable, widely accessible treatment.
1型糖尿病(T1D)的β细胞替代疗法正在经历变革性转变,这一转变由干细胞生物学、基因编辑和组织工程学的进展所驱动。虽然胰岛移植在恢复内源性胰岛素分泌方面已证明概念验证成功,但其临床影响仍受供体稀缺、免疫排斥和操作复杂性的限制。干细胞衍生的β样细胞的出现代表了一种范式转变,初步临床试验显示出有前景的胰岛素分泌。然而,将这些突破转化为可扩展、广泛可及的治疗方法面临重大挑战。与太空探索作类比,本文认为虽然已证明科学可行性,但真正的可及性仍然难以实现。如果没有战略转变,β细胞疗法可能会成为一种精英干预手段,受到成本和基础设施的限制。罕见病基因和细胞疗法的经验教训凸显了不可持续定价和有限市场可行性的风险。为了跨越“最后一英里”,本文提出了一种设计质量方法,从一开始就强调可扩展性、易用性和经济可行性。通过强调实际实施而非学术成就、企业利益、市场经济或专利限制,β细胞疗法可以从概念验证发展成为一种可行的、广泛可及的治疗方法。