Firoz Ahad, Remer Daniel, Zhao Huaqing, Lu Xiaoning, Hamad Eman
Department of Internal Medicine, University of California Davis Medical Center, Sacramento, CA, USA.
Center for Urban Bioethics, Lewis Katz School of Medicine, Philadelphia, PA, USA.
Eur J Cardiothorac Surg. 2025 Mar 28;67(4). doi: 10.1093/ejcts/ezaf141.
Racial and ethnic disparities remain an ongoing challenge in healthcare. Such inequities have been reported in heart transplantation (HTx); however, there is limited data within the modern era. Additionally, there is scarce information on outcomes besides death, such as graft rejection. Therefore, our investigation aims to add further data on contemporary racial and ethnic disparities on post-transplant outcomes.
Adult isolated HTx recipients who were transplanted between 1/2000 and 9/2023 were analysed using the United Network for Organ Sharing (UNOS) database. Inclusion criteria included 'White', 'Black', 'Hispanic' and 'Asian' recipients. Two primary outcomes of interest were analysed: mortality and cardiac allograft vasculopathy (CAV). Survival was assessed using a cause-specific model, whereas CAV analysis utilized a competing-risk approach. Subgroup survival analysis was conducted for patients listed in the years prior to (11/2013-10/2018) and after (10/2018-9/2023) the 2018 heart allocation policy (HAP) changes.
A total of 50 243 patients were included in our analysis. Black recipients were the only group found to have an increased overall (hazard ratio [HR] = 1.30, P < 0.001) and post-HAP (HR = 1.36, P < 0.001) mortality risk. Asian (HR = 1.19, P= 0.001) and Hispanic (HR = 1.15, P < 0.001) recipients had elevated risks of CAV, whereas Black patients had similar risk (HR = 1.00, P = 0.864) as White recipients.
Our investigation suggests that disparities continue to exist for minority groups after HTx. Notably, the 2018 allocation changes may have introduced or exacerbated such inequities for Black recipients.
种族和民族差异仍是医疗保健领域持续存在的挑战。心脏移植(HTx)中已报告存在此类不平等现象;然而,现代时期的数据有限。此外,除死亡外,关于移植物排斥等结局的信息也很少。因此,我们的调查旨在补充当代种族和民族差异对移植后结局影响的更多数据。
使用器官共享联合网络(UNOS)数据库对2000年1月至2023年9月期间接受成人孤立性HTx的受者进行分析。纳入标准包括“白人”“黑人”“西班牙裔”和“亚裔”受者。分析了两个主要关注结局:死亡率和心脏移植血管病变(CAV)。使用特定病因模型评估生存率,而CAV分析采用竞争风险方法。对在2018年心脏分配政策(HAP)变更之前(2013年11月至2018年10月)和之后(2018年10月至2023年9月)登记的患者进行亚组生存分析。
我们的分析共纳入50243例患者。黑人受者是唯一一组总体死亡风险增加(风险比[HR]=1.30,P<0.001)且HAP变更后死亡风险增加(HR=1.36,P<0.001)的群体。亚裔(HR=1.19,P=0.001)和西班牙裔(HR=1.15,P<0.001)受者发生CAV的风险升高,而黑人患者与白人受者的风险相似(HR=1.00,P=0.864)。
我们的调查表明,HTx后少数群体的差异仍然存在。值得注意的是,2018年的分配变更可能对黑人受者造成或加剧了这种不平等。