Choi Seongwon, Oh Daniel, Ham Hyunwook, Carluccio Danilo, Burgess Michael, Bennell Myles, Mayze Luke, Batstone Martin, Breik Omar
Department of Endodontics, School of Dentistry, Loma Linda University, Loma Linda, CA.
Department of Statistics & Data Science, University of California, Los Angeles, CA.
J Surg Educ. 2025 Jun;82(6):103505. doi: 10.1016/j.jsurg.2025.103505. Epub 2025 Apr 15.
Virtual reality (VR) is increasingly being explored in surgical education for its potential to create immersive training environments. However, many VR systems are expensive and require complex setups, limiting their accessibility. This survey study assesses the feasibility of cost-effective VR training on the education of oral maxillofacial surgical trainees and practitioners. Given the limited opportunities for hands-on practice in performing major surgical procedures, cost-effective VR training can provide an essential and accessible platform for developing surgical skills.
Cadaver surgery videos of complex maxillofacial procedures were created in 360° VR and 2D formats and published on YouTube. Trainees enrolled in a cadaver course were surveyed after viewing both formats. Fifteen trainees completed questionnaires comparing their learning experiences, with responses analyzed using Fisher's exact test.
About 73.3% of participants found the VR video improved their understanding of the procedure, and over 75% reported enhanced spatial awareness. However, 86.6% experienced discomfort or motion sickness. In comparison, 66.6% felt the 2D video helped their understanding, and only 40% found it improved spatial awareness. No statistically significant difference was found between the VR and 2D formats for procedural understanding or spatial awareness. Notably, participants rated the VR video as more intuitive and user-friendly compared to the standard 2D video, with the difference achieving statistical significance. Overall, 66.6% preferred the VR format, while 33.3% favored 2D.
This feasibility study highlights the utility of a cost-effective VR solution for enhancing maxillofacial surgery training, providing a practical option for preparing trainees for real-life scenarios.
虚拟现实(VR)因其有潜力创建沉浸式训练环境,在外科手术教育中越来越受到关注。然而,许多VR系统价格昂贵且需要复杂的设置,限制了其可及性。本调查研究评估了具有成本效益的VR训练在口腔颌面外科实习医生和从业者教育中的可行性。鉴于进行大型外科手术的实践机会有限,具有成本效益的VR训练可以为培养手术技能提供一个重要且可及的平台。
将复杂颌面手术的尸体手术视频以360°VR和2D格式制作,并发布在YouTube上。参加尸体课程的学员在观看两种格式的视频后接受调查。15名学员完成了比较他们学习体验的问卷,使用Fisher精确检验对回答进行分析。
约73.3%的参与者发现VR视频提高了他们对手术的理解,超过75%的人报告空间意识增强。然而,86.6%的人经历了不适或晕动症。相比之下,66.6%的人认为2D视频有助于他们的理解,只有40%的人发现它提高了空间意识。在手术理解或空间意识方面,VR和2D格式之间未发现统计学上的显著差异。值得注意的是,与标准2D视频相比,参与者将VR视频评为更直观、更用户友好,差异具有统计学意义。总体而言,66.6%的人更喜欢VR格式,而33.3%的人更喜欢2D格式。
这项可行性研究强调了具有成本效益的VR解决方案在加强颌面外科手术训练方面的效用,为让学员为实际场景做准备提供了一个实用的选择。