Ajumobi Oluwayemisi, Davis Meghan, George Christine Marie, Rosman Lori, Von Dobschuetz Sophie, Watson Crystal, Nuzzo Jennifer B
Department of Environmental Health and Engineering, Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, Baltimore, MD, USA
Center for Health Security, Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, Baltimore, MD, USA.
BMJ Glob Health. 2025 Apr 16;10(4):e019162. doi: 10.1136/bmjgh-2025-019162.
Emerging and/or re-emerging infectious diseases (EIDs) in the East Africa region are associated with climate change-induced environmental drivers. There is a need for a comprehensive understanding of these environmental drivers and to adopt an integrated risk analysis (IRA) framework for addressing a combination of the biological, environmental and socioeconomic factors that increase population vulnerabilities to EID risks to inform biological risk mitigation and cross-sectoral decision-making. The aim of this integrative review was to identify knowledge gaps and contribute to a holistic understanding about the environmental drivers of Crimean-Congo haemorrhagic fever virus (CCHFV), Marburg virus (MARV) and Middle East respiratory syndrome coronavirus (MERS-CoV) infections in the East Africa Region to improve IRA processes at the environment-animal-human exposure interface.
An integrative review search was carried out to identify relevant studies and reports from 2000 to 2024. Searches were conducted in bibliographic databases and global institutional websites. Inclusion criteria were studies and reports (in English) addressing environmental drivers of CCHFV, MARV and MERS-CoV infections across countries in the East Africa region, existing risk frameworks/methodological tools and/or One Health policy recommendations for risk analysis of environmentally driven biological threats.
Of the total number of studies retrieved from database searches (n=18 075) and website searches (n=44), 242 studies and reports combined were included in the review with the majority covering the environmental drivers (n=137), the risk frameworks/methodological tools (n=73) and the policy recommendations (n=32). We identified 10 categories of environmental drivers, four thematic groups of risk frameworks and three categories of policy recommendations. Overall, many of the included records on the risk frameworks/methodological tools expounded on the adoption of ecological niche modelling (ENM) for environmental monitoring of potential transmission pathways of EIDs and other biological threats.
This integrative review recommends the adoption of specialised risk mapping approaches such as ENM for environmental monitoring of EIDs under IRA processes. Findings from the review were used for the conceptualisation of an IRA framework for addressing environmentally driven EIDs.
东非地区新出现和/或重新出现的传染病(EIDs)与气候变化引发的环境驱动因素有关。有必要全面了解这些环境驱动因素,并采用综合风险分析(IRA)框架,以应对增加人群对EID风险脆弱性的生物、环境和社会经济因素的组合,为生物风险缓解和跨部门决策提供信息。本综合综述的目的是识别知识空白,并有助于全面了解东非地区克里米亚-刚果出血热病毒(CCHFV)、马尔堡病毒(MARV)和中东呼吸综合征冠状病毒(MERS-CoV)感染的环境驱动因素,以改善环境-动物-人类接触界面的IRA流程。
进行了一项综合综述搜索,以识别2000年至2024年的相关研究和报告。搜索在文献数据库和全球机构网站中进行。纳入标准是涉及东非地区各国CCHFV、MARV和MERS-CoV感染的环境驱动因素的研究和报告(英文)、现有的风险框架/方法工具和/或针对环境驱动的生物威胁风险分析的“同一健康”政策建议。
从数据库搜索(n = 18075)和网站搜索(n = 44)中检索到的研究总数中,共有242项研究和报告被纳入综述,其中大多数涵盖环境驱动因素(n = 137)、风险框架/方法工具(n = 73)和政策建议(n = 32)。我们确定了10类环境驱动因素、4个风险框架主题组和3类政策建议。总体而言,许多关于风险框架/方法工具的纳入记录阐述了采用生态位建模(ENM)对EIDs和其他生物威胁的潜在传播途径进行环境监测。
本综合综述建议在IRA流程中采用专门的风险绘图方法,如ENM对EIDs进行环境监测。综述结果用于构建一个应对环境驱动的EIDs的IRA框架。