Goeddel Lee A, Hernandez Marina, Koffman Lily, Murphy Zachary, Khanna Ashish K, Robich Michael, Whitman Glenn, Zhou Xinkai, Bandeen-Roche Karen, Muschelli John, Parikh Chirag R, Lima Joao A C, Crainiceanu Ciprian M, Brown Charles, Faraday Nauder
From the Department of Anesthesiology and Critical Care Medicine, Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, Baltimore, Maryland.
Department of Biostatistics, Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, Baltimore, Maryland.
Anesth Analg. 2025 Apr 17. doi: 10.1213/ANE.0000000000007500.
Prior studies identified thresholds for mean arterial pressure (MAP <65 mm Hg) and central venous pressure (CVP >12 mm Hg) beyond which risk for cardiac surgery-associated acute kidney injury (AKI) increases. Optimal hemodynamic targets-that is, where active protection from AKI is observed-are unclear; however, current guidelines suggest maintaining MAP >65 and CVP 8 to 12. The aim of this study was to identify hemodynamic ranges associated with both increased and decreased risk of AKI by evaluating narrow ranges of MAP, CVP, and joint exposure to MAP and CVP concurrently.
In a retrospective cohort study of adults undergoing coronary artery bypass surgery, we fine-mapped the association between AKI and the total number of minutes spent in each of the following narrow hemodynamic ranges: 14 MAP ranges in increments of 5 mm Hg (45-115), 10 CVP ranges in increments of 2 mm Hg (0-20), and 70 joint MAP/CVP ranges. Separate multivariable regression models estimated adjusted odds ratios (aOR) for each range including adjustments for correlations and multiple comparisons across ranges. Joint MAP/CVP ranges were grouped into 5 hemodynamic zones based on contiguity of the ranges and similarity of ORs observed across ranges in a color-coded heatmap. The 5 MAP/CVP zones were included in a single regression model to assess risk for AKI associated with time spent in each hemodynamic zone, independent of time spent in other zones.
In 1199 participants, incidence of AKI was 28%. For every 5-minute spent in each hemodynamic range, risk of AKI was significantly increased in MAP range 45 to 50 (aOR 1.18; P = .002), 50 to 55 (aOR 1.13; P = .001), and 55 to 60 mm Hg (aOR 1.06; P = .001); and significantly decreased in MAP range 90 to 95 mm Hg (aOR 0.85; P <.001). Risk of AKI was significantly increased in CVP range 16 to 18 mm Hg (aOR 1.07; P = .002) and significantly decreased in CVP range 4 to 6 mm Hg (aOR 0.97; P = .025). In joint analyses, both MAP and CVP contributed to AKI risk estimates; risk decreased as CVP decreased within every MAP range and was significantly lower for joint ranges of CVP <8 and MAP >75. In analyses containing all 5 MAP/CVP hemodynamic zones, risk estimates suggested protection from AKI in zone 1 (high MAP/low CVP) and increased risk of AKI in zones 3 to 5 (low MAP/high CVP).
Fine-mapping identified narrow ranges of MAP, CVP, and joint MAP/CVP associated with both AKI risk and protection. This report is among the first to characterize the association between joint MAP/CVP and AKI. Contrary to current guidelines, there was no evidence for protection associated with MAP 65 to 75 or CVP 8 to 12 mm Hg.
先前的研究确定了平均动脉压(MAP<65mmHg)和中心静脉压(CVP>12mmHg)的阈值,超过这些阈值,心脏手术相关急性肾损伤(AKI)的风险会增加。最佳血流动力学目标,即观察到对AKI有积极保护作用的目标尚不清楚;然而,目前的指南建议维持MAP>65且CVP为8至12。本研究的目的是通过评估MAP、CVP的窄范围以及同时暴露于MAP和CVP的联合情况,确定与AKI风险增加和降低相关的血流动力学范围。
在一项对接受冠状动脉搭桥手术的成年人的回顾性队列研究中,我们精确绘制了AKI与在以下每个窄血流动力学范围内所花费的总分钟数之间的关联:14个MAP范围,增量为5mmHg(45-115),10个CVP范围,增量为2mmHg(0-20),以及70个联合MAP/CVP范围。单独的多变量回归模型估计每个范围的调整优势比(aOR),包括对各范围之间的相关性和多重比较进行调整。基于范围的连续性以及在颜色编码热图中观察到的各范围OR的相似性,将联合MAP/CVP范围分为5个血流动力学区域。将这5个MAP/CVP区域纳入单个回归模型,以评估与在每个血流动力学区域所花费时间相关的AKI风险,独立于在其他区域所花费的时间。
在1199名参与者中,AKI的发生率为28%。在每个血流动力学范围内每花费5分钟,AKI风险在MAP范围45至50mmHg(aOR 1.18;P = 0.002)、50至55mmHg(aOR 1.13;P = 0.001)和55至60mmHg(aOR 1.06;P = 0.001)时显著增加;在MAP范围90至95mmHg时显著降低(aOR 0.85;P <0.001)。AKI风险在CVP范围16至18mmHg时显著增加(aOR 1.07;P = 0.002),在CVP范围4至6mmHg时显著降低(aOR 0.97;P = 0.025)。在联合分析中,MAP和CVP均对AKI风险估计有影响;在每个MAP范围内,随着CVP降低,风险降低,并且对于CVP<8和MAP>75的联合范围,风险显著更低。在包含所有5个MAP/CVP血流动力学区域的分析中,风险估计表明在区域1(高MAP/低CVP)可预防AKI,而在区域3至5(低MAP/高CVP)AKI风险增加。
精确绘制确定了与AKI风险和保护相关的MAP、CVP以及联合MAP/CVP的窄范围。本报告是首批描述联合MAP/CVP与AKI之间关联的报告之一。与当前指南相反,没有证据表明MAP 65至75或CVP 8至12mmHg有保护作用。