Mishra Punit, Sheeja Pushpa Raj Retna, Aditi Aditi, Sivakami Muthusamy
PopulationCouncil Consulting, New Delhi, Delhi, India.
All India Institute of Medical Sciences (AIIMS), New Delhi, Delhi, India.
PLoS One. 2025 Apr 23;20(4):e0320041. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0320041. eCollection 2025.
The World Health Organization (WHO) recommends that life-saving Caesarean sections (CS) should account for 10-15% of deliveries. Southern states of India have good obstetric facilities and better public health systems than other parts of India. However, CS rates in select states are considerably higher. This study examines the prevalence and determinants of preventable CS among mothers in select Indian states, specifically the states that have high institutional deliveries (>95%) viz. Andhra Pradesh, Kerala, Karnataka, and Tamil Nadu. It further compares the complications faced by CS and vaginal delivery cases. Data has been derived from a cross-sectional survey, the National Family Health Survey-5. Bivariate and Logistic regression analyses were used. The main outcome measured is Preventable C-sections, defined as per conditions in Robson's criteria of 10-group classification based on obstetric characteristics for a woman. Results show that the preventable CS rates in these selected states were much higher than at the national level. Key correlates were higher education and middle socioeconomic status. The study highlights the need for policy reforms, maternal education, and healthcare system improvements to reduce unnecessary CS in select states of India, where the health system is exceptionally good but , have another health burden in form of demand for unnecessary caesarean deliveries.
世界卫生组织(WHO)建议,挽救生命的剖宫产(CS)应占分娩总数的10%-15%。印度南部各邦拥有良好的产科设施,公共卫生系统也比印度其他地区更好。然而,部分邦的剖宫产率要高得多。本研究调查了印度部分邦母亲中可预防剖宫产的患病率及决定因素,特别是机构分娩率较高(>95%)的邦,即安得拉邦、喀拉拉邦、卡纳塔克邦和泰米尔纳德邦。研究还比较了剖宫产和阴道分娩病例所面临的并发症。数据来自一项横断面调查——《国家家庭健康调查-5》。采用了双变量和逻辑回归分析。主要测量结果是可预防剖宫产,根据罗布森基于女性产科特征的10组分类标准中的条件来定义。结果显示,这些选定邦的可预防剖宫产率远高于全国水平。关键关联因素是较高的教育程度和中等社会经济地位。该研究强调,在印度部分邦,尽管卫生系统非常完善,但存在不必要剖宫产需求这一额外的健康负担,因此需要进行政策改革、开展孕产妇教育并改善医疗保健系统,以减少不必要的剖宫产。