Huang Harvey, Adkinson Joshua A, Jensen Michael A, Hasen Mohammed, Danstrom Isabel A, Bijanki Kelly R, Gregg Nicholas M, Miller Kai J, Sheth Sameer A, Hermes Dora, Bartoli Eleonora
Medical Scientist Training Program, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, MN, USA.
Department of Neurosurgery, Baylor College of Medicine, Houston, TX, USA.
J Neurosci Methods. 2025 Jul;419:110461. doi: 10.1016/j.jneumeth.2025.110461. Epub 2025 Apr 22.
Single pulse electrical stimulation experiments produce brain stimulation evoked potentials used to infer brain connectivity. The choice of recording reference for intracranial electrodes remains non-standardized and can significantly impact data interpretation. When the reference electrode is affected by stimulation or evoked brain activity, it can contaminate the brain stimulation evoked potentials recorded at all other electrodes and influence interpretation of findings.
This specific issue is highlighted in intracranial EEG datasets from two subjects recorded at separate institutions. We present several intuitive metrics to detect the presence of reference contamination, based on artificial similarity between all channels. We also offer practical guidance on mitigating contamination, by switching to a more neutral reference electrode, or by post hoc re-referencing, per stimulation site, to an adjusted common average that is optimized for bias and noise.
Either switching the reference electrode or re-referencing to an adjusted common average effectively mitigated the reference contamination issue. This was evidenced by metrics that indicated increased variability in the latencies and response durations of brain stimulation evoked potentials across the brain, and by increased similarity between experimental runs after re-referencing.
Overall, this study demonstrates the necessity of clear quality checks and preprocessing steps to ensure accurate interpretation of single pulse electrical stimulation data, and it provides a set of statistics and tools to achieve this.
单脉冲电刺激实验产生用于推断脑连接性的脑刺激诱发电位。颅内电极记录参考的选择仍未标准化,且会显著影响数据解读。当参考电极受到刺激或诱发的脑活动影响时,它会污染在所有其他电极记录的脑刺激诱发电位,并影响研究结果的解读。
在分别于不同机构记录的两名受试者的颅内脑电图数据集中突出了这一特定问题。我们基于所有通道之间的人为相似性,提出了几种直观的指标来检测参考污染的存在。我们还提供了关于减轻污染的实用指导,方法是切换到更中性的参考电极,或者针对每个刺激部位,事后将其重新参考到一个针对偏差和噪声进行优化的调整后的共同平均值。
切换参考电极或重新参考到调整后的共同平均值均有效地减轻了参考污染问题。这通过一些指标得到证明,这些指标表明脑刺激诱发电位在全脑的潜伏期和反应持续时间的变异性增加,以及重新参考后实验运行之间的相似性增加。
总体而言,本研究证明了进行明确的质量检查和预处理步骤以确保准确解读单脉冲电刺激数据的必要性,并提供了一套统计方法和工具来实现这一点。