Tsani Tsamara, Pelser Tristan, Ioannidis Romanos, Maier Rachel, Chen Ruihong, Risch Stanley, Kullmann Felix, McKenna Russell, Stolten Detlef, Weinand Jann Michael
Institute of Climate and Energy Systems - Jülich Systems Analysis (ICE-2), Forschungszentrum Jülich GmbH, Jülich, 52425, Germany.
Chair for Fuel Cells, RWTH Aachen University, Aachen, 52062, Germany.
Nat Commun. 2025 Apr 24;16(1):3853. doi: 10.1038/s41467-025-59029-1.
Visual landscape impacts on scenic and populated places are among significant factors affecting local acceptance of large-scale renewable energy projects. Through the combination of large-scale reverse viewshed and techno-economic energy system analyses, we assess their potential impacts for nationwide energy systems. In our case study of Germany, moderate consideration of visual impact by placing renewables out of sight of the most scenic and densely populated areas does not have a significant impact on future energy system costs and design. In contrast, in scenarios assuming high sensitivity to visual impacts, annual energy system costs would increase by up to 38% in 2045. The energy system's resilience would also be compromised due to the increasing reliance on green hydrogen imports and the uncertain mass adoption of rooftop photovoltaics. Our analytical framework facilitates careful planning that considers the visual impact of renewable energy infrastructure, thus enabling socially acceptable deployment while understanding the implications for system costs and transformation pathways.
视觉景观对风景名胜区和人口密集地区的影响是影响当地对大型可再生能源项目接受度的重要因素之一。通过结合大规模反向视域分析和技术经济能源系统分析,我们评估了它们对全国能源系统的潜在影响。在我们对德国的案例研究中,通过将可再生能源放置在最具风景和人口密集地区看不到的地方来适度考虑视觉影响,对未来能源系统成本和设计没有显著影响。相比之下,在假设对视觉影响高度敏感的情景中,到2045年年度能源系统成本将增加高达38%。由于对绿色氢进口的依赖增加以及屋顶光伏大规模采用的不确定性,能源系统的弹性也将受到损害。我们的分析框架有助于进行谨慎规划,考虑可再生能源基础设施的视觉影响,从而在理解对系统成本和转型路径影响的同时实现社会可接受的部署。