Christiansen Alex, Craythorne Shioma-Lei, Crawford Paul, Larkin Michael, Gohil Aalok, Strutt Spencer, Page Ruth
University of Birmingham, Birmingham, UK.
Aston University, Birmingham, UK.
Health Expect. 2025 Jun;28(3):e70226. doi: 10.1111/hex.70226.
Social media influencers are powerful storytellers who function as conduits of public health communication and may contribute significantly to young people's mental health literacy. Influencers who discuss mental health include health professionals, wellness practitioners and experts by lived experience. As yet, there has been no multimodal analysis of how these three influencer types narrate mental health issues. This study critically evaluates 398 TikTok videos to show how three distinct types of influencers construct multimodal narratives around mental health.
Data was collected using the TikTok Research API and annotated for narrative patterns and visual formatting using an inductively created multimodal framework.
The analysis shows important differences between the storytelling practices of health professionals, who inform others through talking head explainers, enactments and stitches, and lived experience influencers who invited shared perspectives on their stories of illness, treatment and recovery through compilations and 'watch as I do this' formats. Wellness practitioners occupy an interdiscursive mid-space, blending the verbal aspects of 'informing' (explainers) with the visual narration of 'shared experience' to promote solutions through recommendation and advertising. The data also highlights similarities between the health professionals and wellness influencers in their use of marketing calls to action, indicating the commercialisation of mental health solutions offered in TikTok videos.
It is concerning that the gap between information and support provided on TikTok may lead to partial and imbalanced development of mental health literacy by adolescent users and that content provided by certain influencer types mimics authoritative and authentic communication but promotes non-medical solutions to mental health, unsupported by evidence.
Twelve young people with lived experience of mental health challenges, aged between 16 and 25, were recruited through The McPin Foundation to form the young people's advisory group (YPAG) for the project. This age range incorporates adolescents and 'emerging adults' who are likely to experience a range of life transitions and encounter challenges in mental health. The group met remotely four times during the study, helping to define the categories of influencers, refining the narrative categories and visual formats for the code book and discussing data examples openly to guide the analysis. Two members of the YPAG were trained and participated as coders in the inter-rater reliability process.
社交媒体有影响力的人是强大的故事讲述者,他们充当公共卫生传播的渠道,可能对年轻人的心理健康素养有重大贡献。讨论心理健康的有影响力的人包括健康专业人员、健康从业者和有亲身经历的专家。迄今为止,尚未对这三种有影响力的人如何讲述心理健康问题进行多模态分析。本研究批判性地评估了398个TikTok视频,以展示三种不同类型的有影响力的人如何围绕心理健康构建多模态叙事。
使用TikTok研究应用程序编程接口收集数据,并使用归纳创建的多模态框架对叙事模式和视觉格式进行注释。
分析表明,健康专业人员的故事讲述方式存在重要差异,他们通过讲解视频、表演和拼接视频来向他人提供信息;而有亲身经历的有影响力的人则通过合集和“看我怎么做”的形式,就他们的疾病、治疗和康复故事邀请他人分享观点。健康从业者占据了一个跨话语的中间地带,将“提供信息”(讲解视频)的语言方面与“分享经验”的视觉叙事相结合,通过推荐和广告来推广解决方案。数据还突出了健康专业人员和健康有影响力的人在使用营销行动呼吁方面的相似之处,表明TikTok视频中提供的心理健康解决方案存在商业化现象。
令人担忧的是,TikTok上提供的信息和支持之间的差距可能导致青少年用户心理健康素养的部分和不平衡发展,而且某些有影响力的人类型提供的内容模仿了权威和真实的交流,但推广的是未经证据支持的心理健康非医学解决方案。
通过麦克平基金会招募了12名有心理健康挑战亲身经历的年轻人,年龄在16至25岁之间,组成该项目的年轻人咨询小组(YPAG)。这个年龄范围涵盖了青少年和“新兴成年人”,他们可能会经历一系列生活转变,并在心理健康方面遇到挑战。该小组在研究期间远程会面了四次,帮助确定有影响力的人的类别,完善编码手册的叙事类别和视觉格式,并公开讨论数据示例以指导分析。YPAG的两名成员接受了培训,并作为编码员参与了评分者间信度评估过程。