Pardiwala Dinshaw N, Desouza Clevio, Jesia Arzan
Arthroscopy and Knee Preservation Service, Centre for Bone and Joint, Kokilaben Dhirubhai Ambani Hospital and Medical Research Institute, Mumbai, Maharashtra India.
Indian J Orthop. 2024 Dec 31;59(4):494-500. doi: 10.1007/s43465-024-01320-2. eCollection 2025 Apr.
An unusual meniscal tear involving avulsion of both anterior and posterior roots of the medial meniscus with extra-articular displacement of the meniscus in the medial soft-tissues has occasionally been observed in high energy knee dislocations. We have termed this tear pattern as a 'floating medial meniscus' lesion. This study aims to define this lesion, report its incidence, assess its impact on surgical timing, describe the repair technique, and evaluate healing rates and outcomes.
We retrospectively analysed a database of multiple ligament knee injury surgeries performed between 2008 and 2022 at a referral centre for complex knee injuries and identified cases with a floating medial meniscus lesion. The surgical procedure involved a combined arthroscopic and medial open approach that addressed the meniscus tear and ligament tears in one stage. Early intervention was defined as surgery within 3 weeks of injury. We evaluated injury characteristics, surgical challenges, and clinico-radiological outcomes at a minimum 2-year follow-up.
Seven patients (all male, mean age 27.2 years) with floating medial meniscus lesions were identified from 341 knees with multiple ligament injuries. Five patients underwent early surgery, while two had delayed intervention. Preoperative MRI effectively identified the lesions. Early surgery facilitated easier meniscus identification, reduction, and repair, whereas delayed surgery posed challenges. At follow-up, all patients had regained a minimum 0 to 130 degrees knee range of motion, with no residual instability or pain. MRI confirmed healed meniscal roots, and the mean IKDC score was 89.5. There were two competitive elite athletes in this series and both returned to their previous level of sports.
Although floating medial meniscus lesions are daunting at presentation, they can be successfully repaired with a systematic surgical approach, resulting in satisfactory functional outcomes. Early surgery enables easier meniscus dissection, reduction and repair.
在高能膝关节脱位中,偶尔会观察到一种不寻常的半月板撕裂,包括内侧半月板前后根撕脱,半月板在关节外移位至内侧软组织。我们将这种撕裂模式称为“漂浮内侧半月板”损伤。本研究旨在明确这种损伤,报告其发生率,评估其对手术时机的影响,描述修复技术,并评估愈合率和治疗效果。
我们回顾性分析了2008年至2022年在一家复杂膝关节损伤转诊中心进行的多韧带膝关节损伤手术数据库,确定了有漂浮内侧半月板损伤的病例。手术采用关节镜和内侧开放联合入路,一期处理半月板撕裂和韧带撕裂。早期干预定义为伤后3周内手术。我们在至少2年的随访中评估了损伤特征、手术挑战和临床放射学结果。
在341例多韧带损伤膝关节中,识别出7例(均为男性,平均年龄27.2岁)有漂浮内侧半月板损伤的患者。5例患者接受了早期手术,2例接受了延迟干预。术前MRI能有效识别损伤。早期手术使半月板更容易识别、复位和修复,而延迟手术则带来挑战。随访时,所有患者膝关节活动度至少恢复到0至130度,无残留不稳定或疼痛。MRI证实半月板根部愈合,IKDC平均评分为89.5。该系列中有2名竞技精英运动员,均恢复到了之前的运动水平。
尽管漂浮内侧半月板损伤在临床表现上令人畏惧,但通过系统的手术方法可以成功修复,获得满意的功能结果。早期手术能使半月板更容易分离、复位和修复。