Britto Marcello, Bakare Ayobami A, Graham Hamish, King Carina
Department of Global Public Health, Karolinska Institutet, Stockholm, Sweden.
Access to Medicine Foundation, Amsterdam, the Netherlands.
J Glob Health. 2025 Apr 25;15:04084. doi: 10.7189/jogh.15.04084.
Access to oxygen therapy is essential for ensuring a functioning health care system. Despite its widespread application across multiple patient groups and all ages, there is a lack of understanding about community perceptions and experiences while receiving oxygen therapy for acute conditions. We aimed to understand patient and caregiver perceptions of oxygen therapy in facility-based settings for acute hypoxemic conditions.
We conducted a scoping review. We searched Medline, Embase, and Web of Science (26 February 2024) for original studies published since 2000 relating to patient or caregiver perceptions and experiences of oxygen for an acute medical need in health facility settings. We used an adapted theoretical framework of acceptability to extract and structure the findings.
Searches returned 10 425 unique records, and 25 articles were included. 20 were from high-income countries, and 18 were qualitative studies. The results showed that patient and caregiver attitudes and feelings about oxygen therapy are strongly influenced by perceived effectiveness, which was almost universally positive. Patients and their caregivers suffer different types of burdens, and these are greater for more advanced respiratory therapies than for simple oxygen therapy. Patient and caregiver understanding of oxygen therapy was low, presenting an opportunity for improved communication. Opportunity costs were highest in caregivers of neonates, who were often separated from their infants for long periods, and out-of-pocket costs were a major consideration in low- and middle-income countries.
In this scoping review, we found distinctions in caregiver and patient burden, and their perspectives of oxygen varied between country income. Intervention coherence - the extent to which the patient and their caregivers understand the treatment - was singled out as the key policy area for improvement. Educational campaigns, like those implemented for previous public health emergencies, could lead to increased public knowledge, and thus acceptability, of oxygen therapy.
获得氧疗对于确保医疗保健系统的正常运转至关重要。尽管氧疗在多个患者群体和所有年龄段中广泛应用,但对于社区在接受急性病氧疗时的认知和体验仍缺乏了解。我们旨在了解在医疗机构环境中,患者和护理人员对急性低氧血症性疾病氧疗的看法。
我们进行了一项范围综述。检索了Medline、Embase和科学网(截至2024年2月26日),以查找自2000年以来发表的关于医疗机构环境中患者或护理人员对急性医疗需求氧疗的认知和体验的原始研究。我们使用了一个经过改编的可接受性理论框架来提取和构建研究结果。
检索返回10425条独特记录,纳入25篇文章。20篇来自高收入国家,18篇为定性研究。结果表明,患者和护理人员对氧疗的态度和感受受感知有效性的强烈影响,这种有效性几乎普遍为积极。患者及其护理人员承受着不同类型的负担,对于更先进的呼吸治疗而言,这些负担比简单氧疗更大。患者和护理人员对氧疗的了解程度较低,这为改善沟通提供了机会。机会成本在新生儿护理人员中最高,他们常常长时间与婴儿分离,而在低收入和中等收入国家,自付费用是一个主要考虑因素。
在这项范围综述中,我们发现护理人员和患者的负担存在差异,他们对氧疗的看法因国家收入水平而异。干预连贯性——患者及其护理人员对治疗的理解程度——被确定为关键的政策改进领域。像之前针对公共卫生紧急情况开展的教育活动那样,可能会提高公众对氧疗知识的了解,进而提高其可接受性。