Suppr超能文献

巴西加强初级医疗服务可及性的远程医疗倡议(UBS + 数字项目):多中心前瞻性研究

Telehealth Initiative to Enhance Primary Care Access in Brazil (UBS+Digital Project): Multicenter Prospective Study.

作者信息

Lamas Celina de Almeida, Santana Alves Patrícia Gabriela, Nader de Araújo Luciano, de Souza Paes Ana Beatriz, Cielo Ana Claudia, Maciel de Almeida Lopes Luciana, Longo Araújo de Melo André, Yokoyama Thais, Pagani Savastano Clarice, Gobi Scudeller Paula, Carvalho Carlos

机构信息

Saude Digital, Nucleo de Inovacao Tecnologica (InovaHC), Hospital das Clínicas, Faculdade de Medicina, Universidade de Sao Paulo (HCFMUSP), Sao Paulo, Brazil.

Divisao de Pneumologia, Instituto do Coracao (InCor), Hospital das Clínicas, Faculdade de Medicina, Universidade de Sao Paulo (HCFMUSP), Sao Paulo, Brazil.

出版信息

J Med Internet Res. 2025 Apr 29;27:e68434. doi: 10.2196/68434.

Abstract

BACKGROUND

Brazil faces significant inequities in health care access, particularly in remote communities. The Brazilian Unified Health System is struggling to deliver adequate health care to its vast population. Telehealth, regulated in Brazil starting in 2022, emerged as a solution to improve access and quality of care. Thus, the Hospital das Clínicas da Faculdade de Medicina da Universidade de São Paulo, in partnership with the Agência Brasileira de Apoio à Gestão do Sistema Único de Saúde, created the Unidade Básica de Saúde (UBS)+Digital project, which aimed to mitigate the lack of medical care in remote areas of Brazil by providing teleconsultation in primary health units (PHUs) across the country. Through teletraining and digital health strategies, the initiative enabled health care professionals to provide remote assistance, improving access to medical care.

OBJECTIVE

To describe the implementation and results of the UBS+Digital project, a telehealth initiative focused on training health care professionals, providing teleconsultations, and monitoring key performance indicators among PHUs in Brazil.

METHODS

The study examined 15 Brazilian PHUs using a multicenter, prospective design. Data were collected through anonymous surveys of patients and physicians, which were recorded in the REDCap (Research Electronic Data Capture) database. PHUs were selected based on criteria such as the absence of an on-site physician and existing technological infrastructure. Synchronous and asynchronous training was provided, focusing on digital health and teleconsultation skills. In loco training included workshops and community events to share experiences and foster local engagement. A community of practice facilitated ongoing knowledge exchange. Teleconsultations followed the person-centered clinical method and Calgary-Cambridge methodology. Key performance indicators were monitored by a dashboard to guide continuous improvement. The transition of operations was managed based on physician availability and project duration. Microcosting analysis assessed the project's economic impact using Brazilian guidelines, with statistical analysis performed using Jamovi software.

RESULTS

From March to November 2023, the project conducted 6312 telehealth sessions. A total of 342 professionals were trained, including participants from all three training modalities that were implemented. The Net Promoter Score for teleconsultations was 97, indicating excellent service quality. Of the teleconsultations, 65.3% (4009/6140) were prescheduled, and 34.7% (2130/6140) were on demand, depending on the family health team organization. Teleconsultations resolved 85% (5219/6140) of cases, with 15% (921/6140) requiring in-person referrals or emergency care. The average absenteeism rate was 15% (1083/7223), and consultation durations were between 15 and 20 minutes, suggesting potential adjustments in scheduling.

CONCLUSIONS

The results highlight the effectiveness of telehealth programs in primary care settings with limited medical professionals. The UBS+Digital project demonstrated that telehealth can enhance health care access, presenting a pioneering model within the Brazilian Unified Health System for digital primary care.

摘要

背景

巴西在医疗保健获取方面存在严重的不平等现象,尤其是在偏远社区。巴西统一卫生系统正努力为其庞大人口提供足够的医疗保健服务。从2022年开始在巴西受到监管的远程医疗,成为改善医疗服务获取和质量的一种解决方案。因此,圣保罗大学医学院临床医院与巴西单一卫生系统管理支持机构合作,创建了基层卫生单位(UBS)+数字项目,旨在通过在全国基层卫生单位(PHU)提供远程会诊来缓解巴西偏远地区医疗服务的不足。通过远程培训和数字健康策略,该倡议使医疗保健专业人员能够提供远程协助,改善了医疗服务的获取。

目的

描述UBS+数字项目的实施情况和结果,这是一项专注于培训医疗保健专业人员、提供远程会诊以及监测巴西基层卫生单位关键绩效指标的远程医疗倡议。

方法

该研究采用多中心前瞻性设计,对15个巴西基层卫生单位进行了考察。通过对患者和医生的匿名调查收集数据,并记录在REDCap(研究电子数据采集)数据库中。基层卫生单位是根据诸如没有现场医生和现有技术基础设施等标准挑选出来的。提供了同步和异步培训,重点是数字健康和远程会诊技能。现场培训包括研讨会和社区活动,以分享经验并促进当地参与。一个实践社区促进了持续的知识交流。远程会诊遵循以患者为中心的临床方法和卡尔加里 - 剑桥方法。通过一个仪表板监测关键绩效指标,以指导持续改进。运营的过渡根据医生的可用性和项目持续时间进行管理。微观成本分析使用巴西指南评估项目的经济影响,使用Jamovi软件进行统计分析。

结果

2023年3月至11月,该项目进行了6312次远程医疗会诊。总共培训了342名专业人员,包括来自所有三种实施的培训方式的参与者。远程会诊的净推荐值为97,表明服务质量极佳。在远程会诊中,65.3%(4009/6140)是预先安排的,34.7%(2130/6140)是按需进行的,这取决于家庭健康团队的组织情况。远程会诊解决了85%(5219/6140)的病例,15%(921/6140)需要面对面转诊或紧急护理。平均缺勤率为15%(1083/7223),会诊时长在15至20分钟之间,这表明在日程安排上可能需要调整。

结论

结果凸显了远程医疗项目在医疗专业人员有限的基层医疗环境中的有效性。UBS+数字项目表明,远程医疗可以增强医疗服务的获取,在巴西统一卫生系统内为数字基层医疗提供了一个开创性的模式。

https://cdn.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/blobs/9699/12076026/d865b4531ec9/jmir_v27i1e68434_fig1.jpg

文献AI研究员

20分钟写一篇综述,助力文献阅读效率提升50倍。

立即体验

用中文搜PubMed

大模型驱动的PubMed中文搜索引擎

马上搜索

文档翻译

学术文献翻译模型,支持多种主流文档格式。

立即体验