Gebru Kibrom Teklay, Gebretnsae Hailay, Adane Harnet, Gebremeskel Negasi, Tadesse Mulat, Hadgu Tsegay, Ayele Brhane, Destefanis Cinzia, Giraudo Maria Teresa, Ricceri Fulvio
Centre for Biostatistics, Epidemiology, and Public Health, Department of Clinical and Biological Sciences, University of Turin, Orbassano, Italy.
Tigray Health Research Institute, Tigray, Ethiopia.
Front Public Health. 2025 Apr 16;13:1553452. doi: 10.3389/fpubh.2025.1553452. eCollection 2025.
The overlapping global crises of war, pandemic, and inflation have hit the poorest countries the hardest. Political and security risks have risen in nearly all nations, with those lacking resources suffering from significant preparedness gaps. Similar to other developing regions, Ethiopia's Tigray has experienced many of these effects. This study analyzes the only available data to assess COVID-19 incidence and mortality trends and identify the key influencing factors.
A quantitative analysis was performed using the available incidence and mortality data from the Tigray region prior to the war and from Mekelle town for the 11 weeks during the war. This analysis was complemented by qualitative insights obtained conducted through interviews. Vaccination data covering the years 2021-2023 were also available for the Tigray region. Multiple datasets were selected for comparison purposes based on their relevance to the research objectives. Key informant interviews were conducted with members of the regional response team. Narrative analysis and a deductive approach were applied for systematic coding and thematic analysis of the interviews using Atlas.ti. The study was conducted from 1 January 2023 to 10 December 2024.
The region established an Emergency Operation Center with seven pillars to coordinate the overall response efforts. The COVID-19 positivity rate before the war varied between 0.97 and 20%. During the war, when services were briefly resumed for 10 weeks in Mekelle city, 3,802 cases were detected from 13,213 tests conducted, resulting in a positivity rate of 28.8%. During the same period, 85 deaths were reported. Only 45.9% of the eligible population was fully vaccinated, while nearly 29% had received only the first dose of a two-dose vaccine. Despite challenges, key opportunities included government commitment, strong communication between local experts and international institutions, and local resource mobilization. However, the crisis exposed the fragility of the health system, leading to a significant loss of life.
While the region initially managed to delay the onset of COVID-19 and maintain lower positivity and fatality rates, the war in Tigray led to severe disruption and the eventual collapse of the health system. As a result, the disease was largely neglected and deprioritized, even after the signing of the cessation of hostilities agreement.
战争、疫情和通货膨胀等全球性危机相互交织,对最贫穷国家造成了最沉重的打击。几乎所有国家的政治和安全风险都有所上升,资源匮乏的国家在应对准备方面存在重大差距。与其他发展中地区类似,埃塞俄比亚的提格雷也受到了诸多此类影响。本研究分析了仅有的可用数据,以评估新冠疫情的发病率和死亡率趋势,并确定关键影响因素。
利用提格雷地区战前以及战争期间梅凯勒镇11周的现有发病率和死亡率数据进行了定量分析。通过访谈获得的定性见解对该分析起到了补充作用。提格雷地区也有2021 - 2023年的疫苗接种数据。基于与研究目标的相关性,选择了多个数据集进行比较。与地区应对团队成员进行了关键信息访谈。运用叙事分析和演绎法,使用Atlas.ti软件对访谈进行系统编码和主题分析。该研究于2023年1月1日至2024年12月10日开展。
该地区设立了一个有七个支柱的应急行动中心,以协调整体应对工作。战前新冠病毒检测阳性率在0.97%至20%之间。战争期间,梅凯勒市短暂恢复服务的10周内,在进行的13213次检测中发现了3802例病例,阳性率为28.8%。同期报告了85例死亡。只有45.9%的符合条件人口完成了全程接种,而近29%的人只接种了两剂疫苗中的第一剂。尽管存在挑战,但关键机遇包括政府的承诺、当地专家与国际机构之间的有力沟通以及当地资源的调动。然而,这场危机暴露了卫生系统的脆弱性,导致了大量生命损失。
虽然该地区最初成功延缓了新冠疫情的爆发,并维持了较低的阳性率和死亡率,但提格雷的战争导致了严重破坏,最终致使卫生系统崩溃。结果,即便在签署了敌对行动停止协议之后,该疾病在很大程度上仍被忽视,未被列为优先事项。