Price Timothy
Population Health Sciences Institute, Faculty of Medical Sciences, Newcastle University, Newcastle upon Tyne, UK.
Am J Mens Health. 2025 Mar-Apr;19(2):15579883251329715. doi: 10.1177/15579883251329715. Epub 2025 May 1.
This qualitative study explores the factors contributing to gender-based inequalities in "deaths of despair" (DoD) - those deaths from suicide, drug overdoses, and alcohol-specific causes - among men in two deindustrialised towns in North East England. Understanding gender-based disparities in these causes of death sheds important light on how social and economic factors intersect with certain facets of masculinity, such as stoicism and self-reliance, to drive vulnerability. Data were collected through semi-structured interviews and one focus group with 54 stakeholders - people whose work is related to DoD, such as mental health treatment and public health practice - and community members in Middlesbrough and South Tyneside, two towns with above average rates of DoD. Participants included both men and women, predominantly of middle-age or older, with most participants unemployed or retired. Data were analysed using Iterative Categorisation, with findings interpreted through thematic analysis. The study generated three key themes: industrial history and masculinity, masculinity and class, and masculinity as a barrier to help-seeking. The findings demonstrate that economic decline following deindustrialisation resulted in distress and created unique risk factors for substance use and self-harm for men. These results suggest that effective interventions to reduce DoD among men in post-industrial settings must avoid pathologising masculinity itself. Instead, strategies should focus on the broader structural forces that undermine men's access to stable, fulfilling employment and offering forms of support that are compatible with masculine identity. By addressing these determinants, interventions can more effectively close gender-based inequalities and reduce the rate of DoD in deindustrialised areas.
这项定性研究探讨了在英格兰东北部两个去工业化城镇的男性中,导致“绝望死亡”(DoD)(即自杀、药物过量和酒精相关原因导致的死亡)中基于性别的不平等的因素。了解这些死因中的性别差异,有助于深入了解社会和经济因素如何与男性气质的某些方面(如坚忍和自力更生)相互作用,从而导致易感性。通过与54名利益相关者(其工作与DoD相关,如心理健康治疗和公共卫生实践)以及米德尔斯堡和南泰恩赛德的社区成员进行半结构化访谈和一个焦点小组收集数据,这两个城镇的DoD发生率高于平均水平。参与者包括男性和女性,主要是中年或老年,大多数参与者失业或退休。使用迭代分类法对数据进行分析,并通过主题分析来解释研究结果。该研究产生了三个关键主题:工业历史与男性气质、男性气质与阶级、男性气质作为寻求帮助的障碍。研究结果表明,去工业化后的经济衰退导致了困扰,并为男性的物质使用和自我伤害创造了独特的风险因素。这些结果表明,在工业化后的环境中,减少男性DoD的有效干预措施必须避免将男性气质本身病态化。相反,策略应侧重于那些破坏男性获得稳定、充实就业机会的更广泛的结构性力量,并提供与男性身份相符的支持形式。通过解决这些决定因素,干预措施可以更有效地消除基于性别的不平等,并降低去工业化地区DoD的发生率。