Nyinawabeza Solange, Niyoyita Jean Claude, Nshimiyimana Emmanuel, Ndayisenga Jerome, Umutoni Angela, Stamatakis Caroline
Kibogora Level Two Teaching Hospital, Nyamasheke, Rwanda.
Field Epidemiology Training Program, Public Health Surveillance & Emergency Preparedness and Response Division, Rwanda Biomedical Center (RBC), Kigali, Rwanda.
Sci Rep. 2025 May 4;15(1):15582. doi: 10.1038/s41598-025-99538-z.
Bacterial meningitis is a significant public health concern, with over 1.2 million cases reported globally each year. Rwanda is at increased risk of meningitis outbreaks due to its proximity to countries that lie in the meningitis belt. Rwanda has been conducting surveillance and recording meningitis outbreak cases across the country since 2012. We evaluated the meningitis surveillance system at Kibogora Level Two Teaching hospital, Nyamasheke district of Rwanda to assess whether the surveillance objectives were being met. The study was cross-sectional, using purposive sampling to select healthcare providers participating in the meningitis surveillance. Rwanda's bacterial meningitis data from 2017 to 2021 was collected from clinical registers and Rwanda's electronic integrated disease surveillance system (eIDSR) from Kibogora Level Two Teaching Hospital catchment area, Nyamasheke district, Rwanda. The study area was chosen because a meningitis outbreak was recorded in the area and its bordering country namely Democratic of Republic of Congo (DRC) prior to the current study period. Information on the participant's demographics, occupation, training, professional experience, and their perception on the surveillance system were gathered using a structured questionnaire. Meningitis surveillance systems attributes including usefulness, acceptability, and flexibility were assessed and categorized as poor (< 50% score), reasonable (50-69%), good (70-90%), or excellent (> 90%) in reference to the study conducted on the evaluation of the meningitis surveillance system in Luanda Province, Angola in March 2017. Data collected from clinical registers and eIDSR were used to assess core functions of the meningitis surveillance system including accuracy in detection of cases, laboratory confirmation of cases, and availability of evaluation reports. Descriptive statistics were analyzed using Microsoft Office Excel. Thirty-one healthcare providers working on meningitis surveillance in the Kibogora Level Two Teaching Hospital were interviewed. During the period under evaluation, 48 suspected cases of meningitis were identified; 43 (90%) met the surveillance case definition, and only 10 (21%) were reported to eIDSR (completeness). Attributes such as flexibility scored good while stability and acceptability scored reasonable. Out of 48 suspected meningitis cases, only 2 (4%) samples were collected from patients and sent to the hospital laboratory for analysis. This study found a good knowledge level of the meningitis surveillance system among healthcare workers; however, the system's core functions, such as notification rate and laboratory confirmation were found to have gaps. The notification rate could be improved by conducting regular refresher courses for healthcare workers supporting surveillance system. Moreover, MoH could enhance the implementation of a national policy requiring mandatory CSF sample testing to confirm pathogens for all suspected cases. Future studies should explore performance-based incentives to improve reporting completeness. Rwanda's experience could provide insights for other low-resource settings facing similar surveillance challenges.
细菌性脑膜炎是一个重大的公共卫生问题,全球每年报告的病例超过120万例。卢旺达由于靠近脑膜炎带的国家,脑膜炎暴发风险增加。自2012年以来,卢旺达一直在全国范围内开展监测并记录脑膜炎暴发病例。我们对卢旺达尼亚马舍克区基博戈拉二级教学医院的脑膜炎监测系统进行了评估,以评估监测目标是否得以实现。该研究为横断面研究,采用目的抽样法选择参与脑膜炎监测的医护人员。2017年至2021年卢旺达的细菌性脑膜炎数据收集自临床登记册以及卢旺达尼亚马舍克区基博戈拉二级教学医院服务区域的电子综合疾病监测系统(eIDSR)。选择该研究区域是因为在当前研究期之前,该地区及其邻国刚果民主共和国(DRC)记录到了一次脑膜炎暴发。使用结构化问卷收集了参与者的人口统计学信息、职业、培训、专业经验以及他们对监测系统的看法。参照2017年3月在安哥拉罗安达省进行的脑膜炎监测系统评估研究,对脑膜炎监测系统的属性,包括有用性、可接受性和灵活性进行了评估,并分为差(得分<50%)、合理(50 - 69%)、良好(70 - 90%)或优秀(>90%)。从临床登记册和eIDSR收集的数据用于评估脑膜炎监测系统的核心功能,包括病例检测的准确性、病例的实验室确诊以及评估报告的可用性。使用微软办公软件Excel分析描述性统计数据。对基博戈拉二级教学医院从事脑膜炎监测工作的31名医护人员进行了访谈。在评估期间,共识别出48例疑似脑膜炎病例;其中43例(90%)符合监测病例定义,但只有10例(21%)上报至eIDSR(完整性)。灵活性等属性得分良好,而稳定性和可接受性得分合理。在48例疑似脑膜炎病例中,仅从患者身上采集了2例(4%)样本并送往医院实验室进行分析。本研究发现医护人员对脑膜炎监测系统的了解程度良好;然而,该系统的核心功能,如通报率和实验室确诊方面存在差距。可以通过为支持监测系统的医护人员定期举办进修课程来提高通报率。此外,卢旺达卫生部可以加强一项国家政策的实施,该政策要求对所有疑似病例进行强制性脑脊液样本检测以确认病原体。未来的研究应探索基于绩效的激励措施以提高报告的完整性。卢旺达的经验可为其他面临类似监测挑战的资源匮乏地区提供借鉴。