Farzaneh Mokhtary, Faghihi Elham, Sanagoo Akram, Jouybari Leila
Student Research Committee, Golestan University of Medical Sciences, Gorgan, Iran.
Faculty of Nursing and Midwifery, Golestan University of Medical Sciences, Gorgan, Iran.
BMC Med Educ. 2025 May 6;25(1):661. doi: 10.1186/s12909-025-07211-w.
Acquiring basic skills and achieving professional competence depends on the quality and quantity of training in the clinical environment. Any defects or inadequacies in the education process will impact the quality and quantity of healthcare services, and ultimately, the health of individuals and society. Given the importance of this issue, the aim of this study is to elucidate the experiences of medical students regarding the educational nature of the clinical environment.
This qualitative study employed a conventional content analysis approach and was conducted in 2024. Data were collected through semi-structured interviews with open-ended questions regarding the experience of the "educational nature of the clinical environment." Participants were from various fields of medical sciences and were recruited using purposive sampling. Data saturation was achieved with 22 participants. Interviews were transcribed verbatim and analyzed according to the method described by Graneheim and Lundman. All ethical considerations for human research, including informed consent and confidentiality, were observed.
From the data analysis, four main categories and eight subcategories emerged: (a) ultimately, you are alone (passion for learning, student under pressure), (b) Instructor under the student's microscope (instructor as a refuge for students, planning for teaching), (c) Half and incomplete clinical environment (lack of resources, unequal learning opportunities), (d) Communication, key to learning in practice (better communication: more learning, accompanying the patient in learning).
The findings of this qualitative study provide significant insights into medical students' experiences in the clinical setting, highlighting the need for a transformative approach to clinical education policies and practices. Students' narratives emphasize the importance of creating an environment that encourages autonomy and active learning and addresses the pressures and challenges they face, such as inadequate resources, high stress levels, and unequal learning opportunities. To improve the educational experience, clinical education policies should prioritize equitable access to learning resources, promote a culture of respect, and collaboration among all healthcare professionals. By addressing these critical areas, clinical education can better prepare future healthcare professionals to navigate the complexities of patient care.
获得基本技能并实现专业能力取决于临床环境中的培训质量和数量。教育过程中的任何缺陷或不足都会影响医疗服务的质量和数量,最终影响个人和社会的健康。鉴于此问题的重要性,本研究旨在阐明医学生对临床环境教育性质的体验。
本定性研究采用传统内容分析法,于2024年进行。通过半结构化访谈收集数据,访谈问题为关于“临床环境教育性质”的开放式问题。参与者来自医学各领域,采用目的抽样法招募。22名参与者实现了数据饱和。访谈逐字转录,并根据Graneheim和Lundman描述的方法进行分析。遵循了人类研究的所有伦理考量,包括知情同意和保密。
通过数据分析,出现了四个主要类别和八个子类别:(a) 最终,你是孤独的(学习热情,压力下的学生),(b) 学生审视下的教师(教师是学生的避风港,教学规划),(c) 不完整的临床环境(资源匮乏,学习机会不平等),(d) 沟通,实践学习的关键(更好的沟通:更多的学习,陪伴患者学习)。
本定性研究的结果为医学生在临床环境中的体验提供了重要见解,强调了对临床教育政策和实践采取变革性方法的必要性。学生的叙述强调了营造一个鼓励自主和主动学习并解决他们所面临的压力和挑战(如资源不足、高压力水平和学习机会不平等)的环境的重要性。为了改善教育体验,临床教育政策应优先考虑公平获取学习资源,促进尊重文化以及所有医疗专业人员之间的协作。通过解决这些关键领域的问题,临床教育可以更好地为未来的医疗专业人员应对患者护理的复杂性做好准备。