François Felicia, Wolfberg Jeremy, Croegaert-Koch Caitlin, Fujiki Robert Brinton, Thibeault Susan L
USC Voice Center, Department of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery, University of Southern California, Los Angeles.
Center for Laryngeal Surgery and Voice Rehabilitation, Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston.
Am J Speech Lang Pathol. 2025 Jul 10;34(4):2324-2333. doi: 10.1044/2025_AJSLP-24-00369. Epub 2025 May 9.
The purpose of this study was to examine transfeminine individuals' goals for gender-affirming voice care and what they consider success in gender-affirming voice therapy.
Fifteen transfeminine individuals completed semistructured interviews prior to commencement of gender-affirming voice care. Interviews explored individuals' voice goals, expectations for treatment, and desired treatment outcomes. Interviews were transcribed and analyzed by four speech-language pathologists with experience in gender-affirming voice using a grounded theory approach. Line-by-line, open, and axial coding were conducted to identify themes and subthemes.
Four dominant themes and 12 subthemes were identified from the interviews. Dominant themes included the following: (a) Individuals hope that voice therapy will reduce adverse voice-related experiences, (b) individuals expect successful voice therapy to facilitate specific voice goals, (c) individuals expect successful voice therapy to facilitate communication across varying contexts, and (d) individuals want specific guidance in voice therapy. Past adverse experiences included being misgendered or feeling isolated due to vocal function. Specific voice goals included having a voice that was perceived as more feminine, higher in pitch, and produced with less mental and phonatory effort. Participants hoped that success in voice therapy would facilitate occupational voice use, phone use, and interactions with strangers. They also expressed a desire for specific strategies or exercises to achieve desired voice changes.
Transfeminine individuals seeking gender-affirming voice training have specific goals and expectations for voice therapy, which are driven by past experiences, interactional partners, and communicative context. Future study should continue to clarify the manner in which patient experiences drive voice outcomes in this population.
本研究旨在探讨跨性别女性个体在性别肯定性嗓音护理方面的目标,以及她们认为在性别肯定性嗓音治疗中取得成功的标准。
15名跨性别女性个体在开始性别肯定性嗓音护理之前完成了半结构化访谈。访谈探讨了个体的嗓音目标、对治疗的期望以及期望的治疗结果。访谈由四名在性别肯定性嗓音方面有经验的言语病理学家进行转录和分析,采用扎根理论方法。进行逐行、开放和轴心编码以识别主题和子主题。
从访谈中确定了四个主要主题和12个子主题。主要主题包括:(a)个体希望嗓音治疗能减少与嗓音相关的不良经历;(b)个体期望成功的嗓音治疗能促进特定的嗓音目标;(c)个体期望成功的嗓音治疗能促进在不同情境下的交流;(d)个体希望在嗓音治疗中获得具体指导。过去的不良经历包括因嗓音功能被误认性别或感到孤立。具体的嗓音目标包括拥有更女性化、音调更高且发声时心理和发声努力更少的嗓音。参与者希望嗓音治疗的成功能促进职业嗓音使用、电话使用以及与陌生人的互动。他们还表达了对实现期望嗓音变化的具体策略或练习的需求。
寻求性别肯定性嗓音训练的跨性别女性个体对嗓音治疗有特定的目标和期望,这些目标和期望受到过去经历、互动对象和交流情境的驱动。未来的研究应继续阐明患者经历在该人群中推动嗓音治疗结果的方式。