Yeung Andy Wai Kan
Oral and Maxillofacial Radiology, Applied Oral Sciences and Community Dental Care, Faculty of Dentistry, The University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong, Hong Kong SAR, China.
Front Oral Health. 2025 Apr 24;6:1584382. doi: 10.3389/froh.2025.1584382. eCollection 2025.
There are multiple portrayals of dentists and teeth in movies. It is largely unclear if the literature has investigated these portrayals. This literature review aimed to identify and analyze the themes, narratives, and symbolic meanings associated with dental portrayal in movies from the existing literature.
Online literature databases, Web of Science, Scopus, and PubMed, were searched to identify relevant papers labelled as articles or reviews. Publications were included if they described or investigated the portrayal of dentists or teeth in multiple commercial movies. Publications were excluded if they were irrelevant to this topic or provided commentary on a single movie only. Finally, 7 publications were identified and reviewed. For each publication, its study design, data source, and genres of movies analyzed were recorded. Key findings were reviewed, such as themes or stereotypes identified, positive vs. negative portrayals, and any impact on public perception elaborated.
These papers were published between 2007 and 2024. Five of them provided qualitative content analysis, whereas 2 provided quantitative content analysis. Three publications consulted Internet Movie Database (IMDb) to identify relevant movies. Many of the publications did not explicitly report very detailed inclusion and exclusion criteria for the selection of movies. The portrayal of dentists was covered in 5 publications. The symbolic meaning of teeth was covered in 2 publications. (One publication covered both dentist portrayal and teeth symbolism.) Scenes of oral hygiene practice were investigated in 1 publication.
The portrayal of dentists in movies has often been negative, which may influence public perception and contribute to dental anxiety. Future research should investigate the impact of these portrayals on audience attitudes and behavior, as this review underscores the need for more empirical studies in this area. Meanwhile, readers should notice that one major limitation of this review is the small number of publications included.
电影中有多种对牙医和牙齿的描绘。目前尚不清楚文献是否对这些描绘进行过研究。本综述旨在从现有文献中识别并分析与电影中牙齿描绘相关的主题、叙事和象征意义。
检索了在线文献数据库Web of Science、Scopus和PubMed,以识别标记为文章或综述的相关论文。如果出版物描述或研究了多部商业电影中牙医或牙齿的描绘,则将其纳入。如果与该主题无关或仅对一部电影进行评论,则排除这些出版物。最后,确定并审查了7篇出版物。记录了每篇出版物的研究设计、数据来源和分析的电影类型。审查了关键发现,如识别出的主题或刻板印象、正面与负面描绘,以及阐述的对公众认知的任何影响。
这些论文发表于2007年至2024年之间。其中5篇提供了定性内容分析,2篇提供了定量内容分析。3篇出版物参考了互联网电影数据库(IMDb)来识别相关电影。许多出版物没有明确报告选择电影时非常详细的纳入和排除标准。5篇出版物涵盖了对牙医的描绘。2篇出版物涵盖了牙齿的象征意义。(一篇出版物既涵盖了牙医描绘又涵盖了牙齿象征意义。)1篇出版物研究了口腔卫生实践场景。
电影中对牙医的描绘往往是负面的,这可能会影响公众认知并导致牙科焦虑。未来的研究应调查这些描绘对观众态度和行为的影响,因为本综述强调了该领域需要更多实证研究。同时,读者应注意到本综述的一个主要局限性是纳入的出版物数量较少。