Mauntel Arian, Settmacher Utz, Tekbaş Aysun
Department of General, Visceral and Vascular Surgery, Jena University Hospital, Friedrich Schiller University Jena, Jena, DEU.
Research Programme "Advanced Clinician Scientist Programme", Interdisciplinary Center of Clinical Research, Jena University Hospital, Friedrich Schiller University Jena, Jena, DEU.
Cureus. 2025 May 7;17(5):e83662. doi: 10.7759/cureus.83662. eCollection 2025 May.
Background Racism in the German healthcare system has received increasing attention, yet its integration into medical education remains limited. Systemic disparities continue to affect racially marked individuals and cultural minorities, underscoring the need to explore how these issues are perceived by future healthcare professionals. This study examines how medical students understand racism and intercultural competence in clinical settings, using the example of Muslim patient care, and compares their perspectives with national-level developments. Methods A qualitative case study was conducted with 65 medical students enrolled in an elective course on ethical aspects of caring for Muslim patients. Participants responded to open-ended questions regarding their motivations, clinical experiences, and educational goals. Responses were analyzed using structured qualitative content analysis (MAXQDA 24©, VERBI, 2024). Results Ten central themes emerged, including communication barriers, limited awareness of culture- and faith-specific practices, and the importance of individualized care. While racism and discrimination were acknowledged, they were addressed less frequently. The reflections aligned with broader observations on structural inequalities and the need for culturally sensitive care. Conclusion The findings reveal notable gaps in intercultural competence among future physicians, with implications for both clinical care and medical education. Students identified relevant challenges but lacked tools to address them confidently. Although preliminary, these results highlight the need to further integrate topics such as racism, religious diversity, and structural discrimination into medical training. Doing so may better prepare healthcare professionals to deliver equitable and patient-centered care in an increasingly diverse society.
背景
德国医疗体系中的种族主义问题日益受到关注,但其在医学教育中的融入程度仍然有限。系统性差异继续影响着有明显种族特征的个人和文化少数群体,这凸显了探索未来医疗专业人员如何看待这些问题的必要性。本研究以穆斯林患者护理为例,考察医学生在临床环境中如何理解种族主义和跨文化能力,并将他们的观点与国家层面的发展情况进行比较。
方法
对65名参加关于照顾穆斯林患者伦理方面选修课程的医学生进行了定性案例研究。参与者回答了关于他们的动机、临床经验和教育目标的开放式问题。使用结构化定性内容分析(MAXQDA 24©,VERBI,2024)对回答进行分析。
结果
出现了十个核心主题,包括沟通障碍、对特定文化和宗教习俗的认识有限以及个性化护理的重要性。虽然承认存在种族主义和歧视,但提及的频率较低。这些思考与对结构性不平等以及文化敏感护理需求的更广泛观察结果一致。
结论
研究结果揭示了未来医生在跨文化能力方面存在显著差距,这对临床护理和医学教育都有影响。学生们认识到了相关挑战,但缺乏自信应对这些挑战的工具。尽管这些结果是初步的,但它们凸显了将种族主义、宗教多样性和结构性歧视等主题进一步纳入医学培训的必要性。这样做可能会更好地让医疗专业人员在日益多元化的社会中提供公平且以患者为中心的护理。