Binney Richard J, Smith Laura J, Rossit Stephanie, Demeyere Nele, Learmonth Gemma, Olgiati Elena, Halai Ajay D, Rounis Elisabeth, Evans Jonathan, Edelstyn Nicola M J, McIntosh Robert D
The British Neuropsychological Society, Open Research Group, London, UK.
Department of Psychology, Bangor University, Bangor, Wales LL57 2AS, UK.
Brain Commun. 2025 Apr 28;7(3):fcaf162. doi: 10.1093/braincomms/fcaf162. eCollection 2025.
Preregistration is the act of formally documenting a research plan before collecting (or at least before analysing) the data. It allows those reading a final research report to know which aspects of a study were decided before sight of the data, and which were added later. This enables informed evaluation of the severity with which scientific claims have been tested. We, as the British Neuropsychological Society Open Research Group, conducted a survey to explore awareness and adoption of open research practices within our field. Neuropsychology involves the study of relatively rare or hard-to-access participants, creating practical challenges that, according to our survey, are perceived as barriers to preregistration. We survey the available routes to preregistration, and suggest that the barriers are all surmountable in one way or another. However, there is a tension, in that higher levels of bias control require greater restriction over the flexibility of preregistered studies, but such flexibility is often essential for neuropsychological research. Researchers must therefore consider which route provides the right balance of rigour and pragmatic flexibility to render a preregistered project viable for them. By mapping out the issues and potential solutions, and by signposting relevant resources and publication routes, we hope to facilitate well-reasoned decision-making and empower neuropsychologists to enhance the transparency and rigour of their research. Although we focus neuropsychology, our guidance is applicable to any field that studies hard-to-access human samples, or involves arduous or expensive means of data collection.
预注册是指在收集数据之前(或者至少在分析数据之前)正式记录研究计划的行为。它能让阅读最终研究报告的人了解研究的哪些方面在看到数据之前就已确定,哪些是后来添加的。这有助于对科学论断的检验严格程度进行明智的评估。我们作为英国神经心理学会开放研究小组,开展了一项调查,以探究我们这个领域对开放研究实践的认知和采用情况。神经心理学涉及对相对罕见或难以接触到的参与者进行研究,由此产生了一些实际挑战,根据我们的调查,这些挑战被视为预注册的障碍。我们考察了现有的预注册途径,并指出这些障碍在某种程度上都是可以克服的。然而,存在一种矛盾情况,即更高水平的偏差控制要求对预注册研究的灵活性进行更大程度的限制,但这种灵活性对于神经心理学研究往往至关重要。因此,研究人员必须考虑哪种途径能在严谨性和务实的灵活性之间取得恰当平衡,从而使预注册项目对他们来说可行。通过梳理问题和潜在解决方案,并指明相关资源和出版途径,我们希望促进经过充分思考的决策制定,并使神经心理学家有能力提高其研究的透明度和严谨性。尽管我们聚焦于神经心理学,但我们的指导适用于任何研究难以接触到的人类样本或涉及艰巨或昂贵数据收集方式的领域。